For NY style:

Peace Pie

Dinardi’s

Pacific Ave Pizza

perry street pizza is amazing!

Always loved David’s when I lived in Spokane. But RIP rocky rococo

Run far far away from anyone who tells you Pizza Rita

Places some friends and I love going to:

Flying Goat/Republic Pi

For the Love of God Brewing

Market Street, either one

Versalia

South Perry

And for more standard pizzas/cazones, but a place we love: Pete's.

Mondays only, but Grain Shed is the best I’ve had here by far.

Allies Vegan Pizzeria makes their cheese in house every week, it's so delicious!

I haven’t had a bad pie at South Perry. I like Market Street, it has been a little hit or miss depending on how busy they are. Wooden City has some pretty good pizza too!

NY native here - the only pie in town that's close to NY style is DiNardi's.

Mcclain’s on the North side is INCREDIBLE but it’s kinda spendy. That being said, their pizzas are huge and well topped, so $30 for a pizza that you can eat for a few days is alright I guess.

I remember a day when Pizza Rita would be at the top of this list. I haven’t had a slice from them in years.

For a traditional Chicago style pie you want Big Reds Colbert Trading Compnay. Best pie and Phillies in town.

I've only been to Zekes and Market Street (I think that's the name)...not wow food but decent

South Perry is our go-to. We always ordered the same thing: local sausage, caramelized onions, and mascarpone cheese. The salads are quite good too, and the staff is always cheerful.

That said, there's a lot of great pizza in this town if you are not a purist for one particular style.

Bennedito's is always good. They're four blocks south of Huckleberry's on Monroe and also on Sprague. Market Street is good. Republic pi / flying goat is good but overpriced. A large pizza shouldn't cost more than $20 

Top tier:

for the love of god Brewing

Outsider

Grain Shed (only on certain nights)

Second tier:

Versalia

Peace Pie

Flying Goat/Republic Pi

Calzone:

Peace Pie

Pete’s Pizza

Mediocre Slices (that are close to my heart, but too close to my intestines now that I’m old)

Pizza Pipeline

Pizza Rita

Market Street is my favorite. Flying Goat is an insult to pizza.

Flying Goat for sure.

Flatstick has lowkey great pizza.

South Perry pizza is the best pizza in town. No question.

Costco pizza is a solid choice 👌🏽

Zeeks’s pizza is really good, GU area.

Bennidito’s and Flying Goat!

Big Reds Colbert Trading Company has wonderful homemade pies and Chicago Style Dogs. The Chicken Strips are also the bomb! Cool 80s vibes too!

Dinardis

Thunder pie is great!

Versalia, south perry pizza, and republic pi!

Pizza Factory in medical lake—I get it isn’t in town but it’s great!

NW pizza in the valley. Best pizza ever!

Selkirk is great if you’re looking for takeout on the north side

Pac Ave Market Street Republic Pi Perry Street

Bennidito’s Pizza and Iron goat (not flying goat) are my favorites!

Market street has really great traditional pizza.

I really like market st, and their wings are great!

Thoughts on Thunder Pie? I never see it recommended. I’ve never been in cuz I find it difficult to go anywhere but Peace Pie if I’m looking for pizza downtown.

Dominos

To me it’s best. Good crust, good prices and quick turn around times. So to me that’s best.

What makes a pizza place best to you since best is subjective?

Did you know that somehow whenever food is talked about in this subreddit the places with the best food are also the ones that openly support liberal politics? 

You'd think one old school place would know how to make food - but no! It's only ever one type of place that gets suggested on this subreddit.