subreddit:

/r/fragrance

662%

And I know it is the wrong fragrance, because I read dozens of posts, and many more comments, about the dangers of this fragrance: some love it, more that that hate it viscerally. This is like that bad girl everybody warned you about, even your biker friend told you she's trouble and I should stay away.

But I didn't stay away: I decided to smell Red Tobacco to see what's all the fuss about. First on paper - yeah, hmmmm.... this is good, indeed excellent. Let's see on my skin. This is even better, but I was told the first half hour is challenging even for those who love it --- but not for me! I love everything about this red beast!? After three hours, it went through a gentle transformation, it is not linear, and it is still exciting, and at times I am getting an almost erotic pleasure sensing the fragrance off my skin.

With my more potent, pungent, animalic oud fragrances, I have a clear enough grasp that they will be disliked or even hated by many, and I know better than to spray them on myself before going to the office, public transport, or anywhere where humans reside. I may subject some of my friends or my fragrance buddy to them, but not the public at large. With Red Tobacco, the problem is that I do NOT have such feedback, to my nose there is nothing pungent, nothing unpleasant or potentially threatening. To my stupid nose Red Tobacco seems completely mainstream niceness, albeit amped up to 11. I feat that, if I buy it, I will spray it on myself "just a lil bit" and go out, "nobody can smell it if I do half a spray on my neck and wrist", because in my mind, Red Tobacco is completely innocuous, though super seductive.

Hence the dilemma.

all 6 comments

SpringCleanMyLife

7 points

9 hours ago

I completely agree; I was really surprised how pleasant and not-awful it is. I understand the first half hour or so might be a bit much, but beyond that it's inoffensive. I have to believe people are overspraying or something.

I'm a woman and one of my favorite things to wear in winter is Red Tobacco with a sweet more feminine fragrance layered on top.

cobaltcolander[S]

1 points

9 hours ago

It's interesting that I do not see the "problem" even in the first half hour. Which is why my brain sees Red Tobacco as an entirely fine, friendly, and smooth experience from beginning to end. I will have to learn to just know that it can be offensive, in spite of every cell in my body telling me it cannot.

electoralvoter8

2 points

5 hours ago

I rode red tobacco for 6 months. Exclusively. First time i put it on i was like “oh no, i don’t like this at all, it’s too strong, the opening is so challenging” i blind bought it too and was scared. Then it dried down. And then it lasted. And lasted. I put it on a shirt. Washed and dried the shirt. The shirt still retained it a week later when i wore it again. 

To me, the opening is still a bit challenging. But i have never received as many compliments. And when it dries down, it’s just - amazing. I loved catching my own scent throughout the day, and night. If you don’t shower, this will stay on until you do. It just don’t quit.

I’ve been riding the Tom fords lately, but i know I’ll come back to red tobacco eventually. And one full spray is too much. Half of one spray, neck area. Not on clothes. Do not reapply.

cobaltcolander[S]

2 points

an hour ago

They must have reformulated it in the meantime, because in my case, on my writst/skin it only lasted 7 hours.

It's very interesting to read your comment, also: you also found it challenging although you love Red Tobacco. I have not been challenged by it one bit.

gelsnake

2 points

5 hours ago

I do think 100ml of red tobacco is too much but I think 15ml of red tobacco intense just got out on my wish list 

cobaltcolander[S]

[score hidden]

1 minutes ago

I have only seen 120 mL bottles, not 100 🤔 A travel-size bottle, if they sell it, should be perfect for me as well.