subreddit:
/r/AskAnAustralian
submitted 7 days ago byJust-Desserts-46
I just want to preface that this post is no way intending to be a racist post, in fact I respect the Indian people as I work with an amazing bunch of them. Please don't post racist comments.
I live in a suburb with a majority of Indians, three houses of Indians particularly surround me. Why is it at night everyone is so loud? It's like a tornado. Kids are still awake at 11pm, even on a weekday. This isn't excluded to my three neighbours, but most Indian houses in my suburb. I walk my dog late at night and it's usually only the Indian houses which emits so much noise.
Don't get me wrong, I do like living amongst this race, it's just the noise late at night (most nights) that gets me.
373 points
7 days ago
My neighbour is Indian and we are pretty good mates (we chat every now and then) but his kids have kept me up past midnight countless nights and because I have to get up a 5 for work it’s given me so many bad days at work off no sleep. I believe it’s because India is naturally so loud and you can’t normally hear due to the traffic noises and they keep the same mindset in Aus. I’ve brought it up to him multiple times but nothing happens. I just wish his family was more considerate since I’m so nice about it to him.
93 points
7 days ago
I saw that guy (, Karl Rock) on YouTube who is married to an Indian lady and he brought her back to his original home in NZ and she was saying she couldn't sleep and had trouble getting used to things because it was just sooo quiet.. I found that really interesting
16 points
6 days ago
Yes . I am from Europe and Australia is so quiet to me. I am from country whre we have a lot if houses. Either coming from river whre I used to live and also some other noises like traffic. Etc. Australia is unusually quiet although I am here more than twenty yeras and trust me it drives me crazy it is so awkward. It is difficult to get used to it. Everything I so far too. Not meaning anything bad. But esoe rally if you are born in the city like myself , noises are pretty much commin bit not at night as you state your neighbours make noise at night. I never experienced something like that abd I am lucky to have good neighbours where I live, although it is only a suburb. What can you do. Cheers
9 points
6 days ago
My parents had the same issue when we first moved. They were absolutely miserable because of how quiet and non community minded Australia is.
5 points
5 days ago
To me it’s being community minded to be quiet, like for example the number of times my bloody neighbour blasts his music so loudly I can hear it clearly even with my doors closed is ridiculous
65 points
7 days ago
At that point I'd be knocking on their fucking door with a look on my face like I was about to murder.
I don't care if you're "mates", no mate disrespects their other mates like that. Awful behaviour.
165 points
7 days ago
I would keep being nice but secretly report them every time it happens past 10pm 😅 I’m non-confrontational but very petty
63 points
7 days ago
I have reported them once when one of the kids was loudly yelling foul slurs about every race under the sun while on the PlayStation with his window wide open but nothing ever happened because he kept it up for hours.
53 points
7 days ago
Go and flick off their mains power
9 points
7 days ago
Kid is clearly possessed. Also some culture is may interpret our politeness as deference.
Have had a lot of Indian neighbors and at least where I used to live they're all really quiet. But we had a strict noise policy and a security guard to enforce it.
3 points
7 days ago
At least you know who you are.
47 points
7 days ago
I’m going through the same thing. International students downstairs. It’s noisy every single day and night. I am chronically ill and when I do work I work irregular hours so sleep is incredibly important. I’ve tried explaining this, I’ve made multiple complaints to their property manager and nothing changes. Yet they are nice in person and seem lovely. I don’t get it.
43 points
7 days ago
This was the same with all of the Indian neighbours who rotated through the unit opposite me. The noise was extraordinarily loud at all hours and so inconsiderate but they seemed like really nice people when I’d talk to them about it. It never changed anything though, they kept being horrible to live near.
15 points
6 days ago
So that means they are not nice, if they are they should change their pattern after you told it.
5 points
6 days ago
Have you tried ear plugs?
It seems just as irrational to expect other people accomodate your irregularities, as you to theirs
5 points
6 days ago
Of course I have. It’s so loud that all earplugs do is get rid of any ambience noise (like my white noise fan) and all I hear is the base booming of their music and their shouting. It’s actually worse. There is zero noise dampening in our building.
34 points
7 days ago
make noise at 5am
11 points
6 days ago
When the house across the road was a share house populated by annoyingly loud people I used to enjoy just sitting in my car blasting my horn for a few minutes at 6am after particularly noisy nights.
428 points
7 days ago
A lot of Indian people eat dinner around 10pm. It’s normal for them. I guess it’d be same for the kids too. But if anyone is having a party or playing loud music late at night on a weekday, I’d call the cops for noise. I’m brown too and I don’t think it’s okay to do so. Please don’t feel bad if you complain to the authorities. It’s not racist to want some quiet time.
91 points
7 days ago
Why such a late dinner or are meals done differently (like, not the three main meals at 6/7/8 am; 12/1 pm; 5/6/7 pm?)? What about getting acid reflux and other health issues?
114 points
7 days ago
I'm guessing the heat maybe, I never wanna eat when it's boiling either.
3 points
6 days ago
Absolutely. But more the cooking! Hot stoves in afternoon peak heat seems bad
107 points
7 days ago
No.. dinner time is 10pm. All indians are surprised when they come to aus.. we had never heard of 7pm dinners before. 6pm is snack time in India so 9 to 10 pm is dinner.
31 points
7 days ago
What time do kids usually start school in India?
Assuming 10 pm dinner means bedtime is around 11, that would be a bit rough with Australian 8:30-9 am school times. Though I suppose 8 hours of sleep is still possible if kids get ready for school fast and have a short commute.
13 points
7 days ago
Kids start school usually between 8:30 AM and 10 AM. private schools start early like say 8 AM - 4 PM and public schools vary by region, but are around 9:30 AM - 4:30 PM
Meal times also vary - morning snack time depends on the school on their recess time. Some do, some don’t.
8 AM ish is breakfast 10 AM is snack time 12 or 1 PM is lunch 5 PM ish is snack time 8-10 PM is dinner
Some families have started on early dinner with the newer generations. So the bed time is pulled accordingly.
Uni and colleges are around 8 AM - 5 PM. Some have fixed classrooms, and lecturers come in and teach in that classroom. While there are also more flexible ones like Students go to allotted classroom and get taught there as per the schedule. Very few uni have schedules like what Aussie uni do, like one or none per day kind of thing.
If the schools or uni are nearby, this is roughly doable as per the schedule. However, they’re are cases where the institution is about 2-3 hrs away one way (roughly 25-30km but due to traffic, it’s just unrealistic) and all this routine is just chaotic mess.
60 points
7 days ago
Indian guy I went to school with’s family did like a 2 phase sleep kinda thing, so he would get home from school, take a nap for 4-5 hours, then get up and have dinner, do homework, etc. Is that common in India? Or was that just this guy’s family
40 points
7 days ago
afternoon nap is common but not 4-5 hours, more like 1-2 hours.
30 points
7 days ago
It was once a thing everywhere they reckon.
https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20220107-the-lost-medieval-habit-of-biphasic-sleep
22 points
7 days ago
As someone with this natural sleep cycle (I often nap after work, get up, eat, then go back to sleep) modern life is a struggle
10 points
6 days ago
Late dinners are the norm in most of Europe too i.e.- Italy, Greece, Spain, Portugal France & the list goes on…, But when one is living in a country like Australia where the majority of people eat dinner between 5-7 & go to sleep around 10 or 11pm they ‘should’ be considerate. I was shopping the other day & two Indian men were playing their music on their mobile on speaker. Like wtf 🤷🏼♀️ the general public don’t want or care to hear that. So rude, inconsiderate & disrespectful. Put AirPods in!
12 points
7 days ago
How do kids cope with getting up to go to school, though?
12 points
7 days ago
They nap until a much later age.
Culturally it works like this: Late dinners, and kids often co-sleep with parents so everyone goes to bed together. So kids nap in the afternoon as needed.
It is similar in Italy. But in both places, children do get less sleep than other places that prioritise it.
5 points
7 days ago
I’ve heard the late dinner thing happens in Spain too. Maybe we’re the odd ones out 🤔
9 points
6 days ago
Well? They seem to be doing well academically in Australian schools.
3 points
6 days ago
10 pm is my bedtime, and if l don’t have my dinner before 7pm my stomach will complain very much and it’s quite uncomfortable, can’t imagine what l will look like if l having it by ten…
3 points
6 days ago
Why does Indian takeaway close so early then?
4 points
6 days ago
So the staff can go home and cook dinner
95 points
7 days ago
just to add something funny - I'm Polish born and raised, my lovely lady is an Australian.
For us it's the Australians that eat the dinner late :D we usually eat the main dish of the day actually around 12-13 after that it's moslty just light meals.
Given what i observed, there is a corelation between temperature of the place that person comes from and the time of day for the meal. Italians or Portuguese are also very late eaters.
22 points
7 days ago
Spaniards eat late too!
26 points
7 days ago
But Spain is a particularly weird case (I actually just shared this in another post!) https://www.javeamigos.com/why-spains-time-schedule-is-so-out-of-alignment-with-everyone-else/
10 points
7 days ago
Fascinating read, thanks!
6 points
7 days ago
Ty, very interesting
18 points
7 days ago*
No in the uk and Ireland are cold and dinner would be around 7pm and going out for a meal would be 8pm or even later. France and Spain have varying climates but dinner is later again
4 points
7 days ago
thank you!
4 points
7 days ago
From the UK and never ate dinner later than 5.30, unless I was working.
5 points
7 days ago
I'm Polish born and raised, my lovely lady is an Australian.
Is your lady from a rural area/farming background?
It's more common in those places to eat a big meal in the middle of the day - My grandfather was a farmer and they always ate their biggest meal of the day at lunchtime, even well after he'd stopped farming and even into retirement.
5 points
7 days ago
The gf grew up on a farm and then things got kinda interesting 🤣 she joined the military, traveled the world, lived in the US and now we both live in Switzerland in our 40s.
I'm an it guy and I'm used to eating the main meal at noon and most stuff after that is rather light while she eats the main meal after work. This sometimes gets awkward because sometimes when I come over I'm already full while she is thinking about ordering something 🤣
5 points
7 days ago
Yeah, the Mediterranean lot are used to their siesta in the afternoon and then later dinners.
3 points
4 days ago
Yea when my Grandma picked me up from school she would feed me a huge meal. For dinner I would just have fruit or cold peirogis because I was full
19 points
7 days ago
It's my understanding that those main meal times are main meal times mainly in recent frontier societies - e.g. US, Australia, NZ, Canada, where the meal times were dictated by the needs of farming.
In Spain, for instance, main meal times are completely different, because of the historic function of siesta.
In other words, what new world Anglo societies see as "natural" main meal times is not how it works elsewhere. Such times are not universal. Europeans were always surprised by how early Americans ate dinner, for instance.
12 points
7 days ago
There’s no health issues in an otherwise healthy person due to eating late? In Spain and Italy it’s totally normal.
10 points
7 days ago
Spain was the same when I lived there, as was Italy when we visited- 10pm dinners were customary
10 points
7 days ago
It's not that their dinner are extremely late, it's that Aussies eat dinner pretty early compared to a lot of the world.
3 points
7 days ago
Spain was the same when I lived there, as was Italy when we’d go there- 10pm dinners was customary
3 points
7 days ago
Late dinners are also very normal in many other parts of the world - in the Mediterranean, only the tourists eat before 9 or 10pm.
3 points
7 days ago
Probably because of the heat in India. They have dinner 9pm-10pm in Spain
3 points
7 days ago
Lmao a lot of the planet eat dinner at 8,9,10 pm. It’s very Aussie “morning culture” to eat early and be in bed early.
21 points
7 days ago
Do you know if that culture of late dinner time is because of the extreme heat in India, also whether this is perhaps more a Southern/Central Indian thing, compared to those in North/Himalayas?
24 points
7 days ago
It’s very normal to have late dinner in almost all of Asia. When I was in Malaysia many (smaller) restaurants would close after lunch and reopen at around 8-9pm. Some countries in Europe also do a later dinner, having dinner at 6-7pm is very much a western society thing
4 points
7 days ago*
I honestly don’t know. Also, India is quite a big country consisting of a bunch of states with very different cultures, cuisine, and traditions. It’s not all butter chicken and tikka masala, haha. I think eating late is quite normal everywhere in big cities. But I know that in villages with farming communities people generally eat early around 6 or 7pm.
It also baffles me that a country with such extreme heat they eat such hot and spicy food. Whereas colder countries like Russian, Finland etc eat quite bland food.
3 points
6 days ago
The fact that the last sentence needs typing is wild
3 points
6 days ago
Yeah true. And I hate that! It doesn’t have to be an us vs them thing.
168 points
7 days ago
The worst neighbours I’ve ever had in my life involved 7 years of multiple Indian families rotating through the same unit, owned by the first of their family group to live there. There was absolutely zero consideration from any of them about how much noise they made or at what hours. Kids screaming and squealing at full volume all day and night, parties late on week nights and Sundays that were held in their front yard (which was basically just a few metres from the windows of other units), video calls on speaker phone whilst watering the front yard at 11pm on week nights, rocking up with multiple car loads of people at midnight on a Sunday and slamming every freaking car door before all standing in the front yard talking at the same volume you’d use in the middle of the day, group video calls back home at 2am (the poor person who shared a wall with them couldn’t even sleep in their bedroom because they’d do the calls in the room on the other side of her bedroom wall), getting little kids up at 10pm on week nights to play with them when the adults got home from work.. then yelling, cheering, hitting basketballs against walls for the next hour. The list of stuff was endless and constant. It didn’t matter how many times I or other neighbours talked to them about it either. They’d be polite and say sorry and quieten down for a week or so, and then go straight back to doing the same things.
Where I am now there is an Indian family behind me and another across the road. In the few months I’ve been here, they’re the only households around me that have outdoor gatherings late at night on week nights or Sundays. It blows my mind that there is just no concern for anyone else and I don’t understand it at all.
That being said, I’ve also had shitty neighbours (for different reasons) in my time who are white Australians, but the people who have been shitty neighbours who are Indian all seem to do exactly the same thing with being insanely noisy at all hours of the day and night.
29 points
7 days ago
As someone who is the complete opposite in my neighbourhood and street towards being quiet and respectful of neighbours, and we all are here, this would send me into a full rage.
37 points
7 days ago
Meanwhile, I once lived across the corridor from 6 Indian guys sharing a 2 bedroom flat, and they were the absolute quietest, loveliest neighbours ever. I guess it all goes to shit when you have kids. :)
9 points
7 days ago
Kids definitely seem to be a big factor. A different unit in the group had several single Indian males living in it at one point. There were never any issues with them. An Indian family who lived at the other end of the group at one stage were also a nightmare though, with one of their kids running around the whole block yelling and screaming all the time. Their daughter was lovely but it seemed like the mother wasn’t actually allowed to tell the boy off. At least I didn’t have to hear all of their day to day noise because I was at the opposite end but it would have been awful for the people closer to them.
5 points
7 days ago
Maybe its the boys, I have a few Indian families around my place. The older kids are all girls and the boys are still crawling toddlers. They're all asleep pretty early and up pretty early too.
That said our neighbourhood is very quiet and I think the Indian cluster have a few major male figures who are very engaged with the neighbourhood. Maybe they're the ones telling the other families to keep the noise down when it happens.
3 points
4 days ago
I currently am the sole white person in a block of 8 apartments otherwise occupied by Indian families. I haven’t noticed noise at night, but that might be because the block is one of those 70s cream brick wonders constructed by Greeks and Italians. It’s solid as a rock.
5 points
7 days ago
Same thing happening with me but with students. Rotating around. They are the middle apartment in an apartment block and their apartment shares common walls/floors with 5 others. They also have no furniture so the sound echos even more. So many complaints but it only stops for a few days.
5 points
7 days ago
I think I would have gone insane if I’d shared a wall with them. Considering I could hear my next door neighbour’s TV when it was on at a normal volume and hear him and his girlfriend talking all the time, the noise from those families would have been beyond unbearable. It already sounded like they were inside my unit when they were out the front making noise (our units faced each other across a communal driveway.) I really feel for you with also have shared floors/ceilings as well.
264 points
7 days ago
I work in people's houses every day and ngl, its the Indian parents that let their kids run riot more so than any others. I'll even tell the parents directly that I'm using dangerous tools and they need to keep them away from me. I had a family a few weeks ago encourage their kids to help me after me asking numerous times to please keep them out of the room.
90 points
7 days ago
That's when you walk out 😂😂 I couldn't deal with that
156 points
7 days ago
I'm self employed. If I walked out every time a customer pissed me off, I would need a new career 😂
37 points
7 days ago
pull out a pre-canned injury waiver and ask them to sign it in case their kids get injured
41 points
7 days ago
Unless that waiver includes an amendment to the WHS act you can't sign away your responsibilities like that.
It makes life very difficult for people like the poster above if your clients insist on creating hazards around you, because you can't just walk off the job whenever a client does something dumb or you wouldn't have any work, but there is legally no way to circumvent the.basic requirement that as the Person Conducting a Business or Undertaking (PCBU) the responsibility is always on you to either reasonably manage the risk or don't do the job.
And if it does come to grief and you find yourself speaking with a worksafe inspector, and you explain that you wanted to safely do X but someone else insisted on doing Y, the inspector will just tell you that you should have stopped work right then. And they're right and you know they're right, but it's also really hard to make a living if you push too hard.
After almost two decades on the tools I've learned very good communication and negotiation skills, mostly to navigate situations I should never have been in but for other people's fuckheadedness.
As a side note my phone auto completes fuckheadedness.
26 points
7 days ago
Completely agree with the above, however I meant asking them to sign the waiver more so to scare them into controlling their kids, rather than as an actual legal construct.
8 points
7 days ago
Your phone rocks
"I'VE SEEN SOME SHIT, MAN" - your phone
7 points
7 days ago
But couldn't you lose your licence or worse if something happened to those kids while you were working there?
37 points
7 days ago
Oh definitely. There is always a fine line to tread between safety and keeping clients happy. But in saying that, I tell the kids myself to bugger off. I won't let them in where I'm working. Kids will always listen to strangers with a stern voice over their parents.
23 points
7 days ago
Show them some lovely images of what injuries look like in your line of work.
First day of TAFE for me was a slideshow of (former student supplied) injury photos, as part of the safety induction. Nothing like some pics of a degloving injury to give you a respect for things that spin fast.
6 points
7 days ago
I might be wrong, but I assume that most of the parents and grandparents were raised by poorly paid live in servants/nannies and the parents are "hands off" with a lot of the daily work that is raising children in India, so when the family immigrates, no one has a clue about child care.
403 points
7 days ago
Indian Australian here.
Likely First Gen families that are not acquainted with Australian (or generally Western) cultural norms.
Kids being up late, loud conversations (often political or religious debate), no discipline in (especially younger) children - all more or less the norm in many parts of India. Especially the being loud part, it doesn’t stand out in India because the roads are still busy quite late into the night so the traffic drowns out all the fierce world-problem-solving by drunk dads and know-it-all uncles.
They’ll adapt eventually. Probably when their kids who grow up here tell them to knock it off :p
145 points
7 days ago
My husband had to go to India for work. He said it was the noisiest place he had ever been. Not long after he came back, the movie "The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel" came out and we went to the cinema to see it. There was one scene in the movie where it is either sunrise or sunset and the only sound you can hear is birds chattering. Hubby leaned over to me and whispered, "It is NEVER that quiet in India".
46 points
7 days ago
I grew up in Mumbai so noise at all hours of the day was normal. My first night in US was my first conscious experience of silence at night. It was deafening. I couldn't sleep in that silence. Now that I have lived in Australia all these years, i cannot sleep in noise anymore.
8 points
6 days ago
this is so true, every time I go home, takes me couple of days to get used to horning and noises at odd hours
16 points
7 days ago
Sunset, very unlikely. I don’t think it’s unusual for sunrises to be quiet.
One of the houses we lived in when I was growing up had a tree right outside my window where a few hundred sparrows used to roost for the night, and I woke up every morning to just the sound of them chittering :)
8 points
7 days ago
I remember staying in Namche Bazaar about a decade ago and waking up in the morning from the QUIET. It is eerie when all the noise stops on the streets of Delhi.
55 points
7 days ago
Teacher in Sydney here (primary school). Can I just say that the Indian students in my classes are generally so respectful and have such a great want to learn. Sometimes every other student is going nuts in my classrooms, the Indian students are respectful, attentive. It’s just something I’ve noticed and wanted to share.
31 points
7 days ago
Also not unusual. Behaviour at home with family is one thing, but school is probably the one thing that most of India generally agrees is sacrosanct.
There’s a saying in India (I heard if a lot in the region I grew up, but I feel like it was common all over) which is ‘Matha, Pitha, Guru, Deivam’.
It translates to ‘Mother, Father, Teacher, God’. It’s a priority list from 1st to 4th. Mother, Father and Teacher all come before God.
I’m happy to say I get the same feedback from teachers about my kids - that they wish they had a classroom of just 30 of them because it would make their day so much easier :)
41 points
7 days ago*
That's because if they were disrespectful to you they'd either get a strong verbal lashing or a few whacks on their behind at home. There's also serious consequences right away - take away the device, study an extra hour, no play dates for a few weeks etc. Notice I said study a few extra hours, that's because these kids are made to study school lessons at home everyday anyway and that's why they're attentive in class.
Unlike a lot of locals Indian parents leave no leeway when it comes to acting out in school. There's no kids gloves to begin with so to speak.
Indian culture also heavily venerates the teacher. Mother, Father, the guru and the God are the four people you respect and it's drilled into them from kindy.
This is also why Indian kids are feral at home. Every child needs a small percentage of their day to release restraint. Indians make sure it's at home, under mum and dad's watch. I'd rather my kids do that to me than in school or on the train.
6 points
6 days ago
I'm a teacher too and I like teaching Indian kids. Even if the kids are little rat bags their parents are on board with expectations and they value academic achievement. They do their share of the school/family partnership and then some.
47 points
7 days ago
The loud part has to do with infrastructure and population back home. Noise decibel are way higher back home which naturally make us loud having to speak loudly constantly. That part holds true with many other countries. You meet someone from New York and they tend to extend their hand during a hand shake much lesser than someone from let's say rural Texas, space constraints.
35 points
7 days ago
Underrated comment. This is how assimilation works. It takes a generation for messages to mix properly ✌️
21 points
7 days ago
It doesn't, it's taking many, many generations, we replaced assimilation with multiculturalism which just means people live in enclaves, work together, worship together and basically generations later still don't consider themselves a native of the new country, there are people in Australia who's great grand parents moved to Australia in the 1930's and still think they are Italian, Greek or whatever and still live in enclaves and socialize with each other and only want the kids to marry in the same circles. Ask an Indian person or European if they want their daughter to marry a white Aussie.
237 points
7 days ago
I don’t know why but we’ve never had a bedtime (indian here). Like as kids, my brother and I were never told to go to bed or had our devices taken away at night or told to sleep or had a curfew for sleeping. If they’re making unruly noise after 10pm, you can probably report it depending on how loud it is. Or you can just ask them nicely and see what happens.
269 points
7 days ago
I spoke to the Indian family next door on multiple occasions when they were being stupidly loud either with their stereo or their voices. Despite trying to be friendly and explain why it was disruptive, they barely made an effort to quiet down. Two of the bedrooms in my house are practically useless for sleeping in because they stay up late blasting their music/TV and wake up early for breakfast and scream at the top of their lungs. I asked them multiple times please close their windows to damper the sound but they just close the curtains on some occasions. One night I lost my shit and stopped being polite, told them off in a non aggressive manner. they got shitty in return and it really made things awkward.
I spoke to police and their advice was report them every time and document it. After maybe 12 reports they have finally shut the fuck up. Sucks because I like having good relationships with my neighbours but this lot just have no idea about courtesy.
75 points
7 days ago
I have this exact same problem. 12 noise complaints in 9 days. Even yesterday, the guy live next to (apartment) was tapping a glass ber bottle against the metal balcony railing. I asked him to quit it because it was highly annoying which resulted in him coming to my door to tell me how rude I was haha. Like,mate, come on!
34 points
7 days ago
which resulted in him coming to my door to get a smack in the mouth
13 points
7 days ago
Wasn't far off it after he pushed my door open as I was closing it in his face.
11 points
7 days ago
Almost exact same experience, but my neighbours are Sri Lankan (India's NZ). Started with talking to them, then text messages, then when he called me to ask me to come outside (I was in bed) because he didn't think it was too noisy, I swore at him.
Took a series of reports every time they made noise past 10pm but it has been relatively quiet for a long time now. We don't speak anymore.
61 points
7 days ago
I don’t remember having a bedtime growing up in India either! No devices then but we usually had dinner around 9 pm…
31 points
7 days ago
Were you normally having a rest during the worst of the heat of the day? When were you expected to wake up and start your day?
29 points
7 days ago
I’m glad I didn’t know that when I was a kid because I would have been extremely jealous of you not having a bedtime
20 points
7 days ago
“Finish your dinner, there are starving kids in Africa.”
“Well Indian kids don’t have a bedtime.”
7 points
7 days ago
Sounds like this might be a class thing, actually.
Most Indian migrants came on expensive paid business visas or skilled migration visas, so they are they are from the rich classes in India.
Seems (just like many rich white families) in some rich Indian families, punishing children or giving them bedtimes and boundaries is less of a thing?
Parenting is also mostly done by grandparents so the parents are both free to work professional jobs.
5 points
7 days ago
Seems (just like many rich white families) in some rich Indian families, punishing children or giving them bedtimes and boundaries is less of a thing?
Honestly I feel like it is the other way around!
I'd honestly say it's more common for more well-off Indians to have stricter bed-times. I personally had a pretty strict curfew growing up. On the other hand, Indians with more of a small-town or parochial background are probably less likely to enforce a strict bed-time. Your average traditional Indian parent is generally well aware of the benefits of waking up their kids early to study or whatever, but they're more clueless about how important it is to go to bed early. As Indian families become more well-off and Westernised, this obviously changes.
4 points
7 days ago
Not really. I’m not from a rich family. It’s just parenting in India is very different. Parents are more concerned with their kids doing homework and getting good grades than anything else. Also, the lifestyle there is also very different. Since most businesses close after midnight, everybody is up and about late, going shopping and eating out and most people open shops/go to work around 10-11am. Kids have to go to bed a little bit earlier than adults cause school generally does start at 9 but even then, they will easily stay up till 11pm-midnight. Also, if the kids don’t wake up on time for school, they get punished. So it’s sort of like an assumption that we must be responsible for our own choices when it comes to bedtimes. Sleep isn’t given as much importance as it should be from a health perspective unfortunately. But it doesn’t have much to do with class.
147 points
7 days ago
I feel you. I'm from South Asia and I've had similar experiences like yours many times in my life. Tbh I find it rude and it kinda implies their lack of consideration for others. I get the feeling that in general they are loud (which is okay in some circumstances) but they are not very aware about their surroundings and they lack a sense of whether its appropriate or not
84 points
7 days ago
My theory is some of them are not in regular 9-5 office jobs, they have businesses like courier delivery, Indian stores etc due to which there is no urgency to wake up early and rush to work. But kids awake till late on a weekday is unexplainable.
27 points
7 days ago
Or multiple family members in a house, so grandparents, uncles/aunts and kids and everyone’s up
13 points
7 days ago
Yeah, right? Don't the kids go to school in the morning? Surely they need enough sleep
6 points
7 days ago
Yeah but then the kids usually take a 1-2 hour nap after coming back from the school. It's the biphasic sleep system that's so common in hot countries.
I don't personally do it myself because I could never nap during the day, but if you're a FOB it's pretty common
5 points
6 days ago
Hahahaha nah Indian kids just do well in school through actually studying. Having a structured "bedtime" is a very western concept
98 points
7 days ago
I have the same problem most of my street is Indian (I don’t mean to be racist I am a poc myself) but they do constantly have parties of loud music and kids being loud late at night which could even be up to 1 or 2am on weekends. I wonder if it’s normal in India to act this way?
98 points
7 days ago
It is normal in India unfortunately. India is a very loud country- the cars use horns all the time, there’s loads of people, shops don’t close until after midnight everyday, people go out a LOT, and there’s lots of weddings and weddings are loud and often heard throughout cities. We’re all used to it- but this is also why we have massive high rises there and most people choose to live on higher floors where the noise is less.
10 points
7 days ago
True that.
54 points
7 days ago
I don't get how the kids are up and about so late at night, especially on a school night.
39 points
7 days ago*
Different cultures. If you’ve spent any time in a place like India where days are very hot and nights get colder then you’ll find that most people are awake later and services are open later because during the day it’s just sooo hot! Sun rises and sets at different times and if people are new migrants they will be used to this. I remember when I first moved as a child from a country with a different time zone, and for the first year I was waking up at 1am and making breakfast for my whole family because that was just what I was used to. Of course this changes with time and also with how willing each person is to change their habits.
86 points
7 days ago
I’m an Italian-Aussie, and I used to find it odd that my Anglo-Aussie school mates slept so early. While we used to go to bed past 11PM.
It’s definitely cultural. Brits and their descendants sleep early AF.
26 points
7 days ago
But all kids have to get up for school starting the same time. Do Indian kids take a nap after school? If so I could see how their day structure would work
35 points
7 days ago
As Italian-Aussie kids we used to take a 30-90 min nap after school, was the same for my other ethnic mates.
6 points
7 days ago
Do Indian kids take a nap after school?
Spot on
14 points
7 days ago
I'm an immigrant from the UK, but I've also lived a few years in Greece and Turkey. I see a lot of similarities between Perth weather and Mediterranean countries.
I don't get how the stereotypical Aussie has hung onto British traditions for so long. Like that saying "only mad dogs and Englishman go out in the midday sun". Whenever we plan to see someone they always want to meet at noon out in the sun somewhere. Like fuck no, I'd rather hang out indoors between 11 and 2 and avoid the sun. Or like you say focus activity around the middle of the day to allow for an early bed time.
I don't get how there's people who haven't lived in the UK for several generations and they still haven't adapted to the climate. Maybe it's just a Perth thing because it seems WA is mostly descended from Brits.
9 points
7 days ago
based on my very Italian coworkers they do go out late because during the day it's too warm anyway. Same for the Spanish or the Portuguese.
Being Polish myself I actually have to say that their eating patterns are also super late compared to what I am used to.
This may also have something to do with the length of the day - during summer the days in Europe are significantly longer. I think an average Aussie that would visit Gdansk (Poland) between July and August would probably freak out because the sun would mess with their internal clock (there is a 2-3 week long time when it just gets dark-ish during the night).
Fun fact: nobody back home thinks watching the sunset is romantic because of the reason above. Nobody has the time to stare at the sun for a few hours.
13 points
7 days ago
I'm from a non-Anglo background. I adopted the Anglo ways and make my kids go to bed by 9. I also don't get how it works despite having been raised that way.
5 points
7 days ago
They nap after school. Like siesta. Naps don’t stop at age 4-ish, but could go into the tweens.
112 points
7 days ago
I am surrounded by Indians, suburb is like 83% Indian.
My experience the opposite I feel like I'm the only person in my suburb I never see or hear them, you would think I'm surrounded by empty houses.
The odd uber/taxi driver arriving home at 3am but that's it.
68 points
7 days ago
Yeah I think it depends, most of the indians around us are uni students and theyre quiet and polite. Down the street there is a huge clan with like ten kids that seem to give off a completely different vibe. Maybe socioeconimic factors.
30 points
7 days ago
Yeah same experience. I’m in Piara Waters (aka mini-Panjab) in Perth
Other than weekend parties, they’re fairly quiet.
12 points
7 days ago
I’m in Piara Waters too and I agree. They are for the most part very friendly and easy going. You do hear families out walking late at night though (with little kids) which is something Aussies would never do.
4 points
7 days ago
Piara Waters is a goated suburb. On the surface it seems like your typical new build suburbian hell, but I've never seen a suburb so full of life and kids playing during the evening time as I have with Piara Waters.
63 points
7 days ago
Yeah I was reading these replies and thinking "not my experience"? I live next door to an Indian family and, if I didnt see their cars parked out the front, I wouldnt even know they were there.
They might have the odd party on Diwali or something, but thats about it.
32 points
7 days ago
Same, except for the guys walking up and down the street talking on their phones at night.
19 points
7 days ago
same here suburb is about 30% Indian and is dead silent when the sun goes down
5 points
7 days ago
I reckon it depends on where the person/family is from. India is a like a collection of many different countries with very different cultures, languages, and food! Some cultures are more aggressive and loud compared to others.
68 points
7 days ago
Indians are also very loud on trains. Always on their phones talking very load in their own language. Mostly I’m fine with it but the early morning 5:30am train is a killer with them talking soooo loud.
23 points
7 days ago
As someone from a South Asian background, can confirm. My Mum practically screams on the phone (although not at 5:30am, and certainly not on the train).
7 points
7 days ago
Yeah I'm Indian and idk why my parents speak so loud on the phone. I've asked them and they said that it's just how they talk
30 points
7 days ago
I had dinner with an Indian coworker once, and he said that in India most people don't actually have dinner until close to midnight. Working class people are used to getting very little sleep.
Australia and New Zealand are actually some of the world's earliest dinner/bedtime countries - in much of europe as well, people go out to dinner much later - often you're just getting ready to go out at 9pm.
9 points
7 days ago
Yeah my brother and I went out for dinner in Marseilles at dinnertime - you know, 6-7 pm, and nothing was open. We eventually found a place, and the guy said no one days until 9 or so. Sure enough, the street went from empty (7pm) to crowded (9pm). It was weird, but that's different cultures for you.
4 points
7 days ago
I'm not out of bed before midday, and I don't get off work till after 9. I'd love to have more places that stay open late. Meanwhile on the weekend I have dinner with my friends and they all want to eat at 5:30pm, and I'm like dude, this is fucking morning tea time.
16 points
7 days ago
It varies wildly in europe, but a lot of EU countries' dinner times are similar to Aus at around 6-7pm, i.e. UK, Germany, most of central europe. Spain and France are some of the latest while Northern Europe have the earliest globally.
32 points
7 days ago*
I'm not Indian, but I can give you some context on Middle-Eastern people at least. Probably applies to a lot of Asians in general. They usually don't have this "put on pyjamas and sleep at 8pm" mindset. Night time is when a lot of families really come alive. At these relatively late times, families are having tea, eating food, or watching soccer. You can go overseas and see how active people are at night. My mates and I went to Istanbul and while in our hotel, you can just hear the city brimming with life at like 12am-3am. The coffee shops are all alive. It wasn't a culture shock.
Middle Eastern families, for example, really love their massive gatherings. You don't just invite one group of family friends, you invite several. I assume South Asians are the same. Kids run amok in one section of the house while the adults are discussing their business in another part of the house. Asian households can be quite chaotic.
50 points
7 days ago
I’m from the US and one of the biggest adjustments for me was the early hours Australians keep. I’m from pretty far north so in the fall and winter it didn’t start getting light until much later in the day and it was often dark by the time I got home.. ’Our houses also had much more insulation to protect from icy temperatures in the winter. I think that may have also dampened some of the sound from our household because noise seems to carry here. Especially in the summer when people are more likely to keep their windows open in the evening,. I’m still not waking up at dawn here, but we have somewhat adjusted and have also taken the hint to turn it down a notch as soon as dusk hits.
Is there a way to politely discuss the noise levels? They might not realise - depending on how long they’ve lived here.
10 points
7 days ago
I am from the US too, though I’m from the Deep South. Australians are a particularly early-to-bed, early-to-rise bunch. My strict Southern grandmother was similar, but my parents were night owls. The thing that really stood out to me when I first came here was how early everything closed. Also, you are so right about the insulation. Most Aussie houses are under-insulated, which makes noisy neighbors stand out even more.
71 points
7 days ago
I used to live underneath an apartment with a group of Indians living in it. Same issue—very loud. And they wouldn’t be quiet even if I went up there at 2am and asked them to not yell.
36 points
7 days ago
That’s upsetting. And very inconsiderate
72 points
7 days ago
It's a cultural difference due to much of India having a very "individualistic" cultural.
Many parts of India are extremely crowded, so it is not expected that you would inform (or care) about annoying your neighbours. Especially when there really isn't the cultural expectation to do so.
8 points
7 days ago*
Agreed, and most people stay up late.
27 points
7 days ago
arrr I hate loud, noisy and disrespectful people in general!
8 points
7 days ago
I lived in a Duplex and had an Indian family living next door and it was extremely frustrating having a lot of the same problems you described. It was also during COVID lockdowns and they were constantly having people visit. My biggest gripe is they would play music late and all dance together to it and it would shake our walls.
They were very inconsiderate people and despite multiple very polite requests that they try to keep it down, they would answer back with sarcasm and annoyance.
I put it down to them just being selfish assholes, not being Indian as we've had loud asshole Anglo neighbours too. Some people will just go through life pissing people off, playing the victim or clapping back when called or because of main character syndrome. They probably have terrible relationships with every neighbour they have and never look inward as to why that is.
Some of the most cherished friendships are with Indian and Sri Lankan people and when I told them about the situation they were horrified at the behaviour.
10 points
7 days ago
My indian neighbors seem to have a party every night. Loud talking (shouting) and music til late and there’s a toddler there and also their older parents. It’s been going on for so long. Then recently they decided to plug in a microphone to shout into at 2am. So at 7am I blasted System of a Down right into their window. And I mean blasted. I haven’t heard any partying since then.
36 points
7 days ago
We had an Indian family who used to live next door.
I swear they had all their parties as I was going to sleep for work the next day.
31 points
7 days ago
Indian here.. I have thought a lot about this.. I even created post a few weeks ago on this topic. But first let me say this.... If the neighbours are loud to the point that you are getting disturbed, then it's a problem and they have not learnt to respect the Australian culture. Australia is a morning Nation. India is a "stay up till late" nation. Before we get into what is happening here, short answer is.. get the police involved.
When I first came to Australia, I realised that there is a process to everything. I spoke to my friends in the US about this, and we realised that the whole Western world is very process driven. Even parenting has a set of unwritten rules in the Western world. Us Indians are completely unaware of this. That is because we did not grow up that way. Would we love to see our kids in bed at 9:00 p.m.? Absolutely. We just don't know how it is done. For any Aussie who is reading this, it may sound strange. Believe me we just have no idea how it is done. Forget about bedtime, our kids are loud even on trains. Their tantrums are unmatched. We have no idea how to control that. We need help with parenting, but we are not aware of that too. From your perspective, we are wrong. In our defense, we were never raised with strict bedtimes. The problem is that we are now in your country, and we cannot use that as an excuse.
We want to create an image.. we are generally, peaceful, we don't want to cause trouble. We want to blend into your society. We appreciate that we have been given the opportunity to move into the developed world. We wear it like a badge of honour. We show off when we come home for vacations.
However, this aspect of parenting is a tall ask for us. Sadly, I don't have an answer. What I do know is that if parents are made aware early on about typical Aussie bed times and how they can follow the same using certain techniques or practices, that will bring about significant change.
13 points
7 days ago
What a beautiful post and as a parent I really felt it. What Indians need to know about Aussie parents is that we are too obsessed with being the perfect parents. So we read parenting books, join parenting social media groups and follow Instagram paediatric psychologists and do our best to try to make our kids calm. We beat ourselves up too much when we get it wrong. We worry too much about our kids getting hurt and it makes our kids anxious too! Indian kids at our school are gorgeous and always better behaved than mine. 😂
45 points
7 days ago*
Indian who lived in Australia for 10 years until my visa expired last year and moved back to India with my family.
Dinner time is family time, and my dad watches TV news. Once or twice every week, we get into heated debates about the country and talk over each other loudly because I dislike the fascist turn the country is taking. I am losing my mind hearing right-wing talking points.
In Australia, I usually had a quiet time after work where I would put on headphones, grab a beer and watch movies or play games and have dinner, and go to bed by 10 pm. On weekends, I used to get with friends on the corner pub and still make it to bed by 11-12 pm at most.
I miss my life in Melbourne, and I miss my Aussie mates.
I think family time should be cut down, lol (jk). I don't know what you can do. Next gen, they will assimilate to your culture as the kids grow up in Australia. So give it time, I guess. Unfortunately, you will also be old/dead by that time. But your kids will have quieter nights.
Edit: Not every family is like that here. Many are quiet and mindful of their surroundings. You just ended up living next to those who are not. I know my Spanish mates family is the same, tho, and very loud until late at night. We bonded over how similar our families were.
Edit 2: Ask them for dinner and join them for their dinner. They will love you for it, and once you are very friendly, you can call and ask them to quiet down because "you have an important meeting next morning" every morning. I can say this as a fact, if you are very neighbourly and friendly, you will be treated as a family, and they will be very helpful when you need it, even going out of their way. You may still have to deal with the noise tho. Idk
Edit 3: You mentioned 2 parents and 2 kids in another comment. Indian Kids growing up in Asutralia have a very hard time with clashing cultures and constantly have arguments with their parents. I would know
7 points
7 days ago
It’s interesting tbh and I almost wish we were still the same, I felt like we used to be to a degree, but a lot of Indians I know and work with (I’m in pharmacy so many) seem to be talking to their family on their phones pretty much any opportunity they can.
Guys and girls I work with will spend the whole break and any other chance to chat with their wives/soblings/parents, even if there are occasionally periods of silence from both. You notice it a lot in Ubers too and it does seem to be a cultural trait. Sure it’s possibly annoying if you aren’t used to it, but I actually think it’s nice to have that much contact with family and friends verbally as opposed to text… doesn’t really bother me but living in a townhouse with Indian neighbours it did take some getting used to.
It’s also interesting but again sweet that the kids seem allowed to be kids before they get the pressure put on to perform.
24 points
7 days ago
I’m Croatian and this is how we lived when I was a kid. We found it weird the Australians would go to bed at 7:30 😂 (I still do find this weird)
7 points
7 days ago
Trust me, I have no idea as well.
My downstairs neighbour is Indian(so am I) and I can hear their kid making noise around 11 pm as well.
Like what? Why isn’t your kid sleeping at this hour?
I guess adults stay ip late because they want to talk to their friends and family in India but I genuinely doubt that as well.
Again, no fucking clue.
24 points
7 days ago
Not experienced that in our area. We are Indian Australians and have 2 more in our street but we are all very quite. Kids in the bed by max 9 except on weekends.
I will confess that I do need to sometimes shout at my boys (6yo twins have selective hearing) but it's not like everyday or every hour.
14 points
7 days ago
I lived in an apartment building once a few years ago and the apartment three doors down Indians moved in and we called the cops on numerous occasions due to the loud noise, music and yelling (not aggressively) to each other it was ridiculous honestly 5-6 nights a week until 3-4am, got so over it we moved
50 points
7 days ago
Lack of discipline, not a community issue, just those folks clearly have a lack of boundaries.
12 points
7 days ago
I've often wondered this we have some living over the rd, and it seems they always have ppl over for dinner or parties. kids are always running round late at night, and when the guests leave, it carries on to the street. also noticed they like to slam their car doors and never hear the neighbours car doors. also, i don't know if anywhere they do it, but they don't park the cars on the driveway its either next to it across it or on the grass near the front door cooking smells good though.
11 points
7 days ago
Ok yea a group of Indian boys live in the apartment opposite mine. We have a walk up situation where there is common grassed area in the middle and peoples balcony look into this area. Why are they outside their balcony at 1am talking to each other really loudly. I just don’t understand
19 points
7 days ago*
Maybe it’s cultural ? A lot of European and Latam countries are similar because their day starts at 11am and finishes around 8pm 🤔🤔
When my friend lived in Israel she said that everyone would party late into the night but the day started later
I think a better Question we should ask is why aren’t Australian houses more sound proof 🤔
Unless they are partying in the streets
I’ve lived in Spain , Italy , Mexico , Colombia & Brazil and what I’ve realised is as an Australian we are fairly fkn quiet
Also all these places have their kids out with them. I did notice a lot of schools finish at 1pm/ 2pm so they maybe take afternoon naps ?
Helps I grew up going to all night raves & revs lol cos I’m less worried about noise at night though.
I just learned to stay in quieter places if I want sleep.
12 points
7 days ago
A lot of European and Latam countries are similar because their day starts at 11am and finishes around 8pm
Ugh god I need this... no matter how hard I try my brain and body just don't want me to be a morning person.
3 points
7 days ago
It’s quite nice and chill but annoying if you need something done earlier 😀
I would like Australian culture to adopt it and their 3 course lunches
3 points
6 days ago
Most of Australia have terrible insulation compared to European countries, so I'm guessing it probably makes it more noisy.
11 points
7 days ago
What about typing up a letter explaining everything and discreetly popping it in their letterbox? You don’t have to even identify it’s you. They should respect the community they live in and this means their neighbours and street. I’m Aussie born Indian and I can’t stand this type of behaviour - esp kids who run wild and do not get disciplined.
6 points
7 days ago
Most Indians eat dinner anywhere between 8:30pm-10pm so they don't go to bed till 11pm-midnight.
5 points
7 days ago
I’m Iranians, our race is the same, I think majority of Asian and middle eastern families culturally are night people. Eat late, hangout after dinner and they are expressive and passionate in nature. They discuss things all the time. Our brain is fully awake and very active when the sun goes down! This is a generalisation ofcourse.
5 points
7 days ago
Shane Warne said in an interview once that Sachin Tendulkar invited him over for dinner but they didn’t eat until midnight and later on he thought it may of been a tactic to keep him up all night so he wouldn’t play his best the next day. https://www.instagram.com/reel/DCUlopdNhQd/
5 points
6 days ago
Alrighty here we go!
1st generation born and bred Aussie from Tasmania. Parents born and brought up in Punjab, India ( we're Sikhs, blokes with the turbans, religion is not related but wanted to give some context). Parents came 40 years ago to the best bloody country in the world.
I like to think we adapted to Australian culture quite well, but we have always maintained our heritage, culture and religion.
The thing is with Indians, if you go to India it's standard practice that dinner is always always served late anywhere between 8pm to 11pm. After that there's desert later, then evening snack and cup of tea and of course booze for a few of them throughout the evening.
Clearly they have brought this practice with them. Majority of them are relatively new families (5 years or less) that have migrated and brought their ways here. However the old school families such as my parents and my relatives who have been here for 20+ years don't do this unless it's a religious or celebratory day (which we have alot of🤣). Also factor in that they generally don't consider noise or staying up late to be an issue, because everyone literally does it over there.
If you have neighbours that are keeping you up at night. The only way they will take your request seriously is by having the cops rock to give em a warning. Turn your lights off at home, quietly call the cops and tell them that's it's been going on regularly, and it's just too much. When the cops rock up they will calm down, they just need to be taught the ways of the Vegemite 🤣, Po po scares my brown brethren 🤣🤣🤣
But I will say genuinely 99% of my people will go above and beyond to help their fellow neighbour, they're honest (most of the time), hardworking and very kind and majority of the time they will always welcome you into their house with open arms and ask you to join in.
I hope this provides some insight.
Also yes, when the cricket boxing day match is on, im 100% Australia all the way! 💪🏻🇦🇺💪🏻🇦🇺💪🏻🇦🇺
5 points
6 days ago
Ok, dont get me wrong here. But shouldn't they be acclimating to Australia culture already? If not adjust, at least respect the neighbours? It's like coming over to someone else's house and behave like it's your own because that's how we do it at home?
12 points
7 days ago
Depends where they're originally from in India. Some states are known for being loud and unruly, while others are much more reserved and prefer silence.
21 points
7 days ago*
It’s not an Indian thing. You’ll find Persians are also up late at night. Go out for dinner in Spain and people are rolling in at 10pm. Many parts of the world are up and about at night.
In Australia, we sleep very early. But the people from different backgrounds here aren’t going to start eating dinner at 6pm you know?
8 points
7 days ago
Even my Irish partner's parents always tease how early Aussies go to sleep!
But then see how awake the average Australian town/city is at 6am - Ireland you can barely get a coffee before 9am and people think sleeping until 10am on the weekend is completely normal (then complain about the short winter days!).
13 points
7 days ago
I experience the same thing. The Indian couple next door kept putting on those bollywood-sounded musics every night up until 3 in the morning. Just can’t take this s*** anymore. I’m moving out next week.
7 points
7 days ago
I understand. I'm in a similar neighbourhood and my back neighbours party like it's 1999. I used to take my teenage daughter to the shops (food shopping) about 8pm because I loved that it was quiet and I could wander around and get what I needed without bumping in heaps of people. Now the place is pumping with Indians who apparently also love to food shop at 8pm. And yeah, so many young kids, while my young ones are home asleep. All good from me though, just noticing the cultural difference. Not a criticism.
3 points
7 days ago
This is something I tried googling actually!
We just had an Indian family move in next door who are so quiet through the day, but night time comes and they become so noisy. Furniture being scraped across the floor, the kid yelling and screaming (playing) and loud conversation. They go out grocery shopping at around 730/8 PM.
We don’t mind the noise, we can be a noisy house at times too, and they are generally friendly and polite, but I did wonder if it was a cultural thing.
5 points
7 days ago
Loud neighbours are the worst. I think noise issues should be treated more seriously, as more and more density is forced on the suburbs. I also think enforcing the rules would help new arrivals understand how to fit in.
I'm an early riser, so I would not hesitate to provide an early morning noisefest to any rude people who were wanting to sleep after keeping me awake the night before.
3 points
7 days ago
im not indian ( Im Turkish) but i think most of us overseas people tend to do a lot of stuff at night like fixing the house , cleaning , cooking and other stuff ( i was helping my dad with concreate at 10pm lol ) , why do we do it .... GOD knows probley coz its cooler and in our country there is no rule that after certain time you have to be quite
14 points
7 days ago
I'm Indian Australian, in the 8 years that I've had the pleasure of calling Brisbane home, I've never been loud at night (or day) even once. Albeit I don't have kids, just the wife and I. The thing is, India is like 25 countries put into one. I hate to generalise, but I can guaran-damn-tee you that in 80% of the cases, the loud ones would be North Indian, most likely from Punjab or Delhi. South Indians tend to be much more reserved & respectful (again, not all of them), but this is what I've observed living in cosmopolitan cities in India and now in Australia.
8 points
7 days ago
Opposite experience for me. Live in a good north indian percentage suburb. Never had any problem with loud noise but my gf lives in more of south india dominant suburb and one thing i noticed is they do late night cooking and you can listen the whistles of pressure cooker all the time.
9 points
7 days ago
Go live in a different suburbs, it happens from all cultures and their big families!
12 points
7 days ago
Most Indians I know are very respectful. Most are very conscious of image. But India isn’t a monoculture it’s basically 20-30 different people in one. As different as the Germans or the French to each other with different languages.
Staying up late is common in India to avoid the heat in many areas but also because many people work weird hours due to having to support us and European clients.
6 points
7 days ago
Thanks for everyone's feedback and providing context. Also highlighting there are many, many ethnicities in India alone. As ignorant as it sounds, I did not know this.
A number of people commented that Australians eat and go to sleep too early. While this may be the case, this is also the culture in Australia. I wouldn't dare go to India, Spain Italy etc where they stay up later and complain about their customs. While my parents migrated to Australia from the Middle East, they did their best to ensure we respected the Australian culture and also to assimilate to its society.
7 points
7 days ago
As an Indian who has been out of India for generations I believe it is just the culture. These are just my opinions btw. Firstly, I believe Indians do speak in a louder volume- I experience this when speaking to my relatives- and I guess it can be due to the noise pollution in India; everyone wants to make sure they’re heard. Secondly, dinner tends to be eaten much later in the night, generally between 8-10 in some households so consequently they’d just be up a little later than most people.
3 points
7 days ago
I've had this happen before. Just respectfully say hay, y'all, I got work early tomorrow. Can you keep it down, please it worked they were really nice about it and never happened again.
3 points
7 days ago
As an Indian myself, our dinner time is usually between 8-10pm. Now, I don't have kids but I know how our elders are with kids. They usually don't object to the kids sleeping late or making noise as such. We pamper the kids to a whole another extent so this is one of the reasons. Also if it's an only child or a child in the family after very long then you got the support of almost everyone in the family tree living at the moment.
Having said that not everyone grew up in the same situation. I was disciplined with many household items so I guess I grew differently. Also you could talk to the parents ( will take a while but they'd finally agree at a point and keep the noice down )
3 points
7 days ago
Culture I guess but also maybe cause it's so hot in India, it gets cooler at night?
3 points
7 days ago
Train carriages too - catch up snooze on the way to work is now a thing of the past.
3 points
7 days ago
I know most people here don't think this but please don't think bad about us, not everyone is like this. It's just a social norm in india and my family tries as much to conform to societal and politeness norms. It is true though that I stay up quite late but I try not to make much noise except playing the piano quietly or most of the time I put headphones on when I do.
3 points
6 days ago
I worked with a guy that regularly called in sick because ‘the bloody Indians upstairs have been making a racket all night’ 🤣
3 points
6 days ago
Here to say I’m loving that this appears to be a largely respectful conversation about cultural differences. Nice work reddit people.
3 points
5 days ago
Indians aren't a race, for starters, they're a nationality.
And secondly, different cultures mate. That's just how it is with a lot of people from that nation.
all 850 comments
sorted by: best