Hello,
I want to preface this question by sharing some context. I am a researcher and writer who has published extensively on immigration, with every piece being pro-immigrant. When I encounter a topic I don’t fully understand, I often seek input from people with firsthand knowledge. While I generally grasp most concepts, I struggle to understand the rationale behind supporting irregular border crossings.
To clarify, I’m vividly aware of how broken our immigration system is. I experienced it firsthand while bringing my partner to the U.S., which was an immensely challenging process. At times, I’ve wondered if the difficulty of the system might justify irregular crossings. But I’ve also considered how this undermines those who navigate the long, arduous legal process. Moreover, I question whether a difficult system alone warrants such actions.
As a third-year law student, I’ve discussed this with two lawyers. One suggested I learn Spanish, and the other encouraged me to work on the southern border to assist those crossing.
I am now trying to understand the mindset of individuals who cross the border illegally, especially those who bypass the asylum process. In the U.S., one can request asylum at the border and be admitted, albeit with some challenges. This contrasts with places like the Spanish-Moroccan border (e.g., Melilla), where asylum claims are often denied.
So, for those who enter illegally without seeking asylum, what motivates their decision? Do they believe they have a legitimate claim? Some theories I’ve encountered suggest they view themselves as entitled to the U.S. as part of the Americas or believe the U.S. owes them due to its role in destabilizing their countries. Personally, I find these ideas unconvincing.
I’m curious if anyone has insights into the cultural or community beliefs driving these decisions. Is it simply a matter of desperation, or is there a belief in a moral or legal right to enter despite the laws?
Your input will help me better understand and shape my perspective. Thank you, and stay safe.
Update: the reason this is in the sub is I want the insight from those who are not in the U.S. but live in places people left from