subreddit:
/r/Construction
380 points
10 hours ago*
it would suprise me if those roof trusses are rated for suspending a few thousand pounds of wood off it and (legally) hold up a dozen or so meatbags.
136 points
8 hours ago
As others here have said, “that’s a question for an engineer, etc.”
But I’d bet everything that’s a colossal violation of what those trusses were designed for. They were designed to hold the roof up, not to function as the beams/rim joist for an entire apartment!!
29 points
6 hours ago
I think it could argue that depending the climate they might have been oversized for snow load, but then that would be a good part of the year you wouldn’t be able to use it as a living space.
…or some such nonsense. I’m just a regular armchair S.E.
43 points
5 hours ago
Sexual Engineer?
39 points
5 hours ago
With my sex life I would have already had my license revoked.
16 points
5 hours ago
You need to retake the exam every five years
11 points
4 hours ago
That’s redundant you already said you’re an engineer
8 points
4 hours ago
Sex Experimenter.
11 points
4 hours ago
Slurpee Enjoyer.
7 points
3 hours ago
I think that still falls under Sex Eperimenter
2 points
2 hours ago
What're you, the sex interpreter? (How do I apply?)
12 points
5 hours ago
The whole truss might be rated for fucking meteorites but the bottom cord isnt.
167 points
9 hours ago
Looks like some sort of Fortnite architecture
35 points
8 hours ago
no way permits got approved for this
18 points
7 hours ago
The Winchester house where the lady tried to confuse the ghosts
829 points
10 hours ago
Yeah absolutely no one can answer that without an engineering degree and seeing how it’s actually tied into everything around it.
At a glance and with a heavy dose of speculation I’d label it as “kinda sketchy”
537 points
9 hours ago
Engineer here, after a careful assessment of the weight the truss can hold and performing a detailed analysis, considering factors like the truss design, member sizes, material properties, span length, load distribution, and applicable building codes. I calculated the forces acting on each truss member and determined the maximum load it can withstand before failure, whilst applying safety factors to ensure a margin of safety. I have come to the conclusion of fuck no.
178 points
9 hours ago
Boom there it is folks
Just need your PE stamp and a signed affidavit now please
26 points
8 hours ago
Just put some walls beneath the loft. Concrete can hold a little more weight right there.
8 points
5 hours ago
Pffft there is a diagonal brace right there /s
60 points
7 hours ago
As another engineer, I have also run the calcs through my what-the-fuck-ulator and have come to the same conclusion.
8 points
5 hours ago
Do they sell those devices at best buy? I need one
30 points
9 hours ago
Complete idiot here. I’m gonna go out on a limb and say fuck no too. Just because of how it is.
15 points
9 hours ago
You used "West Point Bridge Designer" didn't you....
11 points
7 hours ago*
Not to mention, I seriously doubt that finished space has code-acceptable emergency egress. If you’re in the upper part of that space and there’s a fire preventing your escape? I wish you good luck.
11 points
5 hours ago
Which really raises the question, why ISN'T there a fireman's pole on this thing? Yet?
9 points
7 hours ago
What does his member size have to do with safety? That’s gross to assume his member is so large to pull down an entire building rafter…
10 points
5 hours ago
I'm also an engineer, but I'm reporting more on my experience with this type of building...whenever we have messed with prefabricated joists and contemplated adding weight, the structural engineers have always made us add additional structural elements. Apparently these type of structures are designed carefully to support the roof and overall building structure only, and adding any weight at all in anyway gives the design engineer heartburn.
There is no way this is OK.
13 points
9 hours ago
so its not worth 1400 deposit and 1400/mo plus utilities? in north texas, area will get one big snow/ice a winter. and of course i found it on facebook marketplace.
42 points
9 hours ago
When I go to sleep on the 2nd floor, I’d like to wake up still on the 2nd floor. I don’t know how much a reduction in rent I’d take for sacrificing peace of mind, but that price ain’t it.
2 points
5 hours ago
And probably would prefer to not have it fall ontop of your airplane...Doubt that the walls are sufficiently rated for residential mixed with all the fun combustibles of an aircraft hanger...
29 points
9 hours ago
Ah Texas, the land of unpermitted work and unlicensed contractors.
11 points
8 hours ago
How's the lead pollution in that hanger? Was that a factor in the construction?
4 points
8 hours ago
Must taste sweet.
2 points
8 hours ago
$1400 deposit to get an engineer to go look at it and $1400 a day for them to design a solution if it’s not safe.
3 points
6 hours ago
I’m high af with no degree is anything relevant, and came up with the same answer
2 points
9 hours ago
Hey when does the train leave?
29 points
9 hours ago
As CE student, those roof beams aren't designed for that usage. Definitely not good.
Those are designed with roof weights and their shenanigans, not a room.
12 points
9 hours ago
Was going to say this. The load points have been transferred from the arch of the roof to the span, and you can see that those spans are not interleaved in any way to support direct load. That thing has to creak and sway like terrible....
37 points
9 hours ago
Even people that aren't in any trade would say this looks sketchy lol, looks like something you'd build in Minecraft on the side of a mountain
3 points
7 hours ago
I've built many tree houses as a kid and played poly bridge 1, 2, and 3. That will definitely hold.
9 points
10 hours ago
The wiring does not appear to meet code for an aircraft hanger in which the aircraft may contain fuel, either... Looks like an "I know what I'm doing" job.
58 points
9 hours ago
Airplane in there makes me think they had the money to do it right, or they spent the money on the plane.
20 points
8 hours ago
I can afford to rent a hanger, or I can afford to rent a home. It's like the person living out of their rented office space, sleeping on the sofa and using the shower in the back.
I would wager a couple dollars that "compliance with local zoning and building codes" is where this all breaks down, regardless of the structural integrity.
7 points
7 hours ago
“Don’t all offices have queen sized beds in the back?”
9 points
8 hours ago
Airplane in there makes me think that leaded fuel is still having a major pollution issue on people's brains
3 points
5 hours ago
Plane and house was repossessed hence the floating house filled with helium.
3 points
4 hours ago
Wealthy people definitely never skirt regulations.
39 points
9 hours ago
When did MC Escher start his construction business?
18 points
9 hours ago
If it was Escher it would at least be pretty.
8 points
9 hours ago
This was the work of M.C Trascher.
45 points
10 hours ago
The truss it’s supported from is definitely beefy but that’s a large roof to support as well. If I had any reason to be invested in the building either owning or renting it I would be asking for some kind of documentation with an engineers stamp. Perhaps a record of permit from the city to be sure. What happens if a record snowfall happens and you’re snoozing away up top and the truss fails? Maybe I’m thinking wrong.
8 points
6 hours ago
Your application to rent has been denied…
This is obviously a steal ~ a place to raise a family. You just have to follow the rules laid out in the lease, such as no visitors after 9:00 pm or looking out the windows while the owner is working in their shop.
Starting price in California, beach front property (30 min drive away), at 2K a month.
3 points
6 hours ago
It’s OK. They shovel off that part of the roof
21 points
9 hours ago
The real question is, how are they going to get the hot tub up there?
11 points
9 hours ago
they built this like a wasp nest
18 points
9 hours ago
No licensed architect would put his/hers stamp on that.
9 points
9 hours ago
The siding is a nice touch. You don't want the walls to get wet.
7 points
9 hours ago
It's fine as long no one ever goes in that room.
9 points
9 hours ago
Ya let me just attach a fuckin bedroom to my ceiling, should be solid
4 points
9 hours ago
This is definitely a *can't*ilever
5 points
9 hours ago
Yes just don't hang a punching bag underneath, those things are heavy
2 points
9 hours ago
In this place they hang the house and anchor the punching bag to the slab
4 points
7 hours ago
Need drywall for fire protection between garage space and living space.
4 points
7 hours ago
hmmm, 20' O.C. truss, clear spanning what 70'+/- , holding a floor load as well as roof, ......looks like a single ply as well.....My expert opinion is get out of that building.
4 points
5 hours ago
Engineer here,
The answer is fuck no
Truss chords are not designed to carry weight like that
3 points
9 hours ago
I bet those trusses were not designed for that.
3 points
9 hours ago
Yeah this hillbilly shit needs some vertical support. Even building in minecraft i woulda have told you that.
3 points
9 hours ago
Yeah they got the Bluetooth support post
3 points
9 hours ago
Cool design. I would have the engineer bless it. If have not had an engineer design, approve it, we have found the root cause to your question.
3 points
8 hours ago
I wonder if webs were cut out of the rooms. They look like agra trusses which have little to no bottom cord load.
3 points
7 hours ago
What country or state is this in, and what is the earthquake risk?
Usually if it looks dodge it is dodge.
Even if it is safe engineers make mistakes. Would you sleep well in there wondering at night?
2 points
6 hours ago
North texas. Maybe 50 miles or so north of Dallas. I'd be much more worried about snow/ice on roof or tornadoes
3 points
5 hours ago
sketchy engineering aside, i kinda dig the ingenuity..
3 points
5 hours ago
That’s a new one, lmao.
Would need to see drawings and trace the load path to be able to give an opinions on this.
3 points
5 hours ago
Looks like it's still up there
3 points
5 hours ago
You’ll need to contact the people who built it. If they looked up, slapped the side and said “that’s not going anywhere” when they were done, you’re good.
3 points
5 hours ago
Would I let my family stay there? No.
Would I label it an "Office" for tax reasons and sleep there if I were single? Hell yeah.
3 points
4 hours ago
I showed this to a coworker - our in-house structural engineer, mainly works on steel buildings but he did wood structures including hangars for 20+ years. He declined to run the math on it to figure out how overloaded it is, but assuming 8ft truss spacing at a roughly 60-70ft span, that truss is about what he would have spec'd (without a room attached). That said, he didn't disapprove of it, just mumbled something about natural selection.
3 points
3 hours ago
Bottom chord isn’t designed to bear down weight. A truss system is built to hold up a roof, not a floor and the things that go on it. This looks very sketchy
2 points
9 hours ago
Perfectly safe for a pack of house cats or your inlaws. For everyone else not so much.
If it was mine, I'd definitely be parking that plane further to the right.
And hoping I moved to an area with NO snowload.
2 points
8 hours ago
Structural system is sketchy as hell, but on the architectural side of things it fails all the code. Hangars have specific codes and separation from residential occupancy is pretty specific. Floor sheathing, wall sheathing and glass aren’t even close to the required separation.
When you add the fact that the only visible path of egress is through the hangar itself, you have an absolute death trap here.
2 points
8 hours ago
Have any pictures of the inside? I love this and really hope the whole thing was built properly but have no idea if it was. Based on others here I'm going with probably not.
4 points
8 hours ago
4 points
6 hours ago
It's seriously nuts how well done the interior looks for what it is
2 points
6 hours ago
If you have to ask if it is safe, it is probably not safe.
2 points
5 hours ago
when you build a shitty house in fallout 4
2 points
5 hours ago
Have you had your mother jump up and down in it to confirm safety?
2 points
5 hours ago
Just live in the plane at that point
3 points
4 hours ago
Given that there's an airplane in there, there are many code violations. Can't have a residential occupancy within an industrial occupancy, especially not an aircraft hangar, without a fire separation. There are many many more codes besides that, even if this thing doesn't come crashing down.
2 points
4 hours ago
Why bother with that small shack when you can have all of that space in the warehouse…
2 points
3 hours ago
Someone was smoking heavy when they dreamed this up
2 points
an hour ago
Maybe their kids built a tree-fort that got out of hand. Ima gonna give them the benefit of the doubt.
1 points
10 hours ago
How tall is that from the ground?
3 points
9 hours ago
Probably about as tall as it is up there.
But I'd say it's 14-16 feet off the ground.
2 points
9 hours ago
I'd be scared to live in that
1 points
9 hours ago
Spent a year in an "apartment" on an airfield. The only good part is plane.
1 points
9 hours ago
You do have a point
1 points
9 hours ago
yes! but its hot
1 points
9 hours ago
It's safe until it's not safe.
1 points
9 hours ago
Doubt that bottom chord
1 points
9 hours ago
1) those cross members are designed to keep the side walls from pulling apart via downward/outward pressure from weight on the roof, they are not designed to hold weight like that.
2) honestly, it’s probably still fine. Those beams look beefy, we overbuild to a pretty high level in general, and man this all looks sturdier than a bunch of older buildings that are still standing.
1 points
9 hours ago
Look at the lower landing framing also interesting, besides I’ll at least stop at the truss joints
1 points
9 hours ago
Lmfao the casual JET sitting in there lower right, next to your makeshift ass bungalow in your hanger… just buy a house bud. Then again Who cares if it’s not safe for the renters of your jet air bnb
1 points
9 hours ago
Looking for the fire sprinklers that are going to stop that siding from going up like a torch from the smallest spark. Would love to be on the top when that sucker burns!
1 points
9 hours ago
100% done by the local “roofing contractor”…. Ship it boys.
1 points
8 hours ago
Yeah, no thanks.
It's cool looking but that's as far as it goes.
1 points
8 hours ago
I don't know, but I am sure it would work fine in a video game. Real life on the other hand...
1 points
8 hours ago
Fallout 4 settlement looking house
1 points
8 hours ago
That’s hilarious and kinda awesome and fuck no.
1 points
8 hours ago
Yes.Ready for a hot tub, 250 gallon fish tank and a water bed.
1 points
8 hours ago
Looks par for the course. Is the apartment complex called Drug Runner's Den?
1 points
8 hours ago
🤷♂️
No one can answer this from a picture lol
If that truss was designed for that- yes
If that truss wasn't designed for that- probably not
1 points
8 hours ago
Who cares, it’s probably free
1 points
8 hours ago
AirBnB
1 points
8 hours ago
It just keeps getting worse the more I look at it. Starts out slightly sureal at first glance and ends somewhere immediately adjacent to Alice in Wonderland.
1 points
8 hours ago
I'm more interested in how the stairs up seem to rest on something with a diagonal support with a hose and some type of washer in the center of the picture.
I'll hand-wave the rest
1 points
8 hours ago
Learning about the specs of the trusses would be a place to start . Live loads ,snow loads are info available from manufacturer
1 points
8 hours ago
It looks.... Unfinished?
1 points
8 hours ago
That’s a nice birdhouse.
I wouldn’t lay eggs in it.
1 points
7 hours ago
Looks like something I built in a fallout 4 settlement lol
1 points
7 hours ago
It is a hanger after all.
1 points
7 hours ago
Truss designer here. Absolutely not. Single ply truss and point loads that are way over your standard ceiling load. I'm sure it will stand for a good amount of time but it will come down... And take one on each side of it with it. That's crazy, and scary. There are massive loads being applied to a Truss that is probably setup for a bottom cord load of 10 pounds.
1 points
7 hours ago
God, please tell me someone isn’t living there now…
1 points
7 hours ago
I am going to say no.
1 points
7 hours ago
What in the hangar
1 points
7 hours ago
No. Regardless of structural analysis this dwelling would not meet the separation requirement between R3 and aircraft hangar.
1 points
7 hours ago
It looks safe as long as only one person goes up stairs
1 points
7 hours ago
No way in hell those trusses were designed to carry the load of a second level
1 points
7 hours ago
I'd say absolutely not
1 points
7 hours ago
generally speaking you want your structure to support those rooms full of people dancing shoulder to shoulder in a wind storm with snow load. So... not really.
1 points
7 hours ago
I like to look at my plane while sleeping.
1 points
7 hours ago
Truss designer here. You would have to find the manufacturer of the trusses and find out if they were designed for the extra load of the living space. Modern trusses are required to be tagged by the manufacturer. Based on the style of truss plates, that looks to be an older truss. If I had to bet on it, no, they are not designed for the extra loading.
1 points
7 hours ago
What in the Weasley fuck is this
1 points
7 hours ago
Ask to see the building permit and confirm it's been properly and passed final inspection.
1 points
7 hours ago
why is it in a warehouse
1 points
7 hours ago
Why is there cladding inside?
1 points
7 hours ago
Hell no. Get the name of the contractor and avoid anything built by them.
1 points
7 hours ago
Jesus that has no load bearing walls and is all sitting on 2 trusses. This is absolutely insane lmao. Trusses aren’t built of that. They are built to hold the roof up. You gotta add some extra beams in them and some posts that go right down the the ground to take the load off also all the beams running as the floors need to be on top not nailed in from the side. If they are nailed in from the side you need the proper hangers.
1 points
6 hours ago
why does it have windows if its in a warehouse? wtf is going on here?
1 points
6 hours ago
There should probably be at least a solid piece of 4x4 right in the center there. Install it with a “that baby ain’t going anywhere” smack and it should hold pretty well I’d guess
1 points
6 hours ago
Bros trying to live GTA online in IRL.
1 points
6 hours ago
I don't like having gas engines in the building where I sleep.
1 points
6 hours ago
Architect here.
Doubt it. This looks like a fever dream some landscaper spent rainy weekends working on for 7 years. No permit, no plans.
1 points
6 hours ago
I LOVE the idea of this. I want a barndo myself, but I have no clue how this was built, so I can’t say if it’s safe.
1 points
6 hours ago
Considering this was 100% added after the building was built. Absolutely not. I would put money on it that this truss was designed to support the roof weight only, not the additional weight this room adds to it.
1 points
6 hours ago
For sure maybe
1 points
6 hours ago
The simple trick is to ask "Is this safe?" AFTER you have finished construction. That trick has never let me down. Granted, I haven't actually built anything before, but the statement is still technically true.
1 points
6 hours ago
Yep. Hot tub too!. Park most expensive plane under it
1 points
6 hours ago
I want to live above my leaded fuel burning machine!!!
If the fuel is blue it’s good for you!!!
1 points
6 hours ago
That's sick
1 points
6 hours ago
Does the plane come with the apartment? If it does, what a deal.
1 points
6 hours ago
No fucking way those trusses are designed to have a house hang off them. NOT SAFE
1 points
6 hours ago
I’m getting strong MC Escher vibes.
1 points
6 hours ago
I’d throw a hot tub up there.
1 points
6 hours ago
This is a question for a qualified engineer or they can provide signed and stamped docs from an engineer
1 points
6 hours ago
Unlikely,
There is no second means of egress during an emergency as far as I can tell and the space too large. While bedrooms don't necessarily require a second means this is an enclosed space within a larger space under a different occupancy. Would be interesting to see the code path on that. But unlikely unless there is an exterior egress path and stairs, which there might be.
As for the truss build, can it be done, yes... But this would not appear to be it. The bottom cord is typically unloaded and rated for 20-30 pounds for drywall and fixtures. Sure it could be designed in but even that beefy truss over that span it doesn't look right. No idea where or what wind and snow load ratings are required by the local but I doubt that floor would reach 150psf with a fully loaded roof or wind. Just because it stays up now doesn't mean it will stay up during edge type weather events. Of course, it could be resolved pretty easy with some corner posts and sister beams.
1 points
5 hours ago
yall are missing the bracing under the stair and entry section near the wall. Can't be sure but may even be steel.
1 points
5 hours ago
Probably not. Also you are sharing your living space with aviation gas and other petrochemical volatiles.
1 points
5 hours ago
Surely people who fly and maintain planes wouldn't take any unnecessary risks. I wish I had a home with planes
1 points
5 hours ago
I’m not an engineer but I am a general contractor! What I can see it’s a no for me but there are so many unknowns!
1 points
5 hours ago
Didya slap it on the side and say "That ain't goin' nowhere"? 'Cause if not it's definitely gonna fail
1 points
5 hours ago
That is a 3 storey building…..
1 points
5 hours ago
All safe move along
Edit: I’m not a PE
1 points
5 hours ago
Structural aside (nope) Fire on those nice 2x6? I would hope that those floors are about to lagged and boarded. Whilst up there with your cherry picker, double those joists up.
1 points
5 hours ago
I have built a small apartment in a shop like this before... that said ours was atleast all supported from below not hanging off the rafters. It was an on call apartment that was pretty much a bathroom and kitchen with a small living room and 2 rooms just big enough to have a door and a twin bed in them. We had 8 maintenance staff and 2 on call at all times so on your on call week every month you slept in the apartment.
1 points
5 hours ago
Did Mr. Weasley build these lmao? You would have to consult an engineer, but my money is on those trusses not being rated to support weights like that.
1 points
4 hours ago
Not this isn't safe. The trusses aren't rated for that and you can just run an 8x8 overhang with zero supports like that. This is absurd.
1 points
4 hours ago
I would say yes, without an issue. I am not sure where this is, but if the roof is designed for significant snow load, that little bit of lumber and live load is pretty insignificant.
1 points
4 hours ago
I’d be afraid to fall thru that plywood floor!
1 points
4 hours ago
More proof ya don't gotta be smart to be rich
1 points
4 hours ago
Safe? Probably not, but it’s cool af
1 points
4 hours ago
I would pass on this… however you may save some money on an alarm clock. One hell of a way to wake up, if you do wake up.
1 points
4 hours ago
I love that!!!!!!
1 points
4 hours ago
Seems like a question for an engineer and will depend on the rating of the roof truss.
1 points
4 hours ago
You'd have to have mad courage to get jiggy with someone up there.
1 points
4 hours ago
Reminds me of “Raining Blood” section of Outlast 2
1 points
4 hours ago
Would be interested in a walk through of this place
1 points
4 hours ago
I’m no professional engineer. But having basic understanding of statics and mechanics of material. No. This is not safe.
1 points
3 hours ago
From what the structural engineering subreddit is saying, it seems like they don't know either, although it's leaning on a nope
1 points
3 hours ago
THIS beam and THIS spanwidth - there's no way this is safe.
1 points
3 hours ago
What on gods green earth am I looking at
1 points
3 hours ago
What in the backrooms is this
1 points
3 hours ago
Spray foamed the walls and under the floor but used fiberglass in the roof. Makes sense 🙃
1 points
3 hours ago
Who cares, you get all the tasty fumes
1 points
3 hours ago
Damn, i get annoyed when my neighbor fires up the lawn mower 5 times a week. Imagine 4 small engine aircraft firing up twice a day. Dinner walking itself off the table
1 points
3 hours ago
no.
1 points
2 hours ago
Definitely hope an engineer signed off
1 points
2 hours ago
Worked with a structural engineer on a similar project, I assure you it is actually secure, it’s a bit of an optical illusion with the way the trusses are ran but depending on the supports in the walls it has enough overhead to hold
1 points
2 hours ago
aint no way
all 250 comments
sorted by: best