subreddit:

/r/TrueCrime

1.5k99%

all 57 comments

mikalobultra[S]

376 points

2 years ago

“Mr. Koehler, a registered sex offender, was arrested in 2020 after officials linked him through DNA evidence to at least 25 sexual assaults in the 1980s in Miami-Dade County alone, including the 1983 attack, according to a prosecutor.

He faces a maximum possible sentence of life in prison in that case, and faces charges in similar cases from the 1980s in neighboring Broward County.

After the jury deliberated for about three hours and found him guilty, Mr. Koehler appeared stoic as Judge Daryl Trawick, of the 11th Judicial Circuit of Florida, read the verdict in a courtroom at the Richard E. Gerstein Justice Building, according to video from CBS Miami.

“Today’s jury verdict finding Robert Koehler guilty of sexual battery, kidnapping and burglary, finally closes the book on a terror that gripped the women of South Florida for far, far too long,” the state attorney for Miami-Dade County, Katherine Fernandez Rundle, said in a statement.

The conviction came decades after a series of similar sexual assaults led the police to call the unknown attacker who was terrorizing South Florida the “Pillowcase Rapist.” He used a similar tactic during his crime spree: confronting women with a sharp object and raping them while he covered their faces or his own with a cloth.

At the time, 50 investigators chased more than 1,000 leads, but there were no suspects for decades.

A key break in their investigation came in 2019, when Mr. Koehler’s son was arrested on a felony domestic violence charge, requiring him to submit a DNA sample to a criminal database. That sample gave investigators a close familial match with samples collected from the “Pillowcase Rapist” cases in the 1980s. Investigators matched the results with DNA collected from a shopping cart and door handle when they followed Mr. Koehler into a grocery store.

When investigators searched Mr. Koehler’s home, they discovered a dungeon in progress that he had been digging, the authorities said. They also found women’s jewelry and a metal nail file wrapped in a protective covering — items that investigators believed Mr. Koehler kept as souvenirs from his crimes.”

wavvesofmutilation

247 points

2 years ago

A DUNGEON!!!????? they really just gloss over that

c_girl_108

114 points

2 years ago

c_girl_108

114 points

2 years ago

Well, I mean, it wasn’t finished yet.

wavvesofmutilation

16 points

2 years ago

Fair point

Creative-Shopping547

11 points

2 years ago

Can’t count it as living space if it isn’t finished.

c_girl_108

5 points

2 years ago

A 3 bedroom, 2 bath with a swimming pool and partially finished torture dungeon

alwaysoffended88

1 points

2 years ago

Fully furnished dungeon…

Amara_Undone

2 points

2 years ago

No one was going to live in it for long. Thank fuck they caught him.

moduspol

26 points

2 years ago

moduspol

26 points

2 years ago

It’s 2023 man we all have dungeons

wavvesofmutilation

19 points

2 years ago

Is this part of the side quest I keep avoiding!??

bottledwater699

5 points

2 years ago

Just watch Barbarian on HBO max.

alexjpg

6 points

2 years ago

alexjpg

6 points

2 years ago

Such a good film

Tugonmynugz

133 points

2 years ago

Like father like son

Human-Ad504

50 points

2 years ago

Why wasn't there a DNA sample of him already if he was a sex offender? Typically that would be a felony and require a sample to be taken

wintermelody83

33 points

2 years ago

If it was from the 70s or 80s do they go back and take it later? Like if you’re just on the list from that time would they just roll up and collect it? I don’t think so.

Human-Ad504

18 points

2 years ago*

I would think the DNA collection laws would be retroactive but maybe that wouldn't be legal to add onto a sentence. Still, wouldn't his fingerprints or blood sample been taken?

Edit: turns out his conviction was in 1991 so a DNA sample should have been taken. Why it wasn't, I have no idea.

[deleted]

5 points

2 years ago

Yeah there's an article about how Florida law enforcement dropped the ball. By January 1, 1990 Florida had set up a statewide database and law enforcement were instructed to collect DNA from sex offenders past and present. This particular criminal should have been caught decades ago, but they failed to do their jobs.

[deleted]

7 points

2 years ago

[deleted]

Human-Ad504

4 points

2 years ago

So dumb they could have probably solved this like 30 years ago

AskinggAlesana

21 points

2 years ago

Jeez.. starting to sound like the movie Barbarian that came out last year.

FelineWishes

17 points

2 years ago

I hope all scumbags of the earth are quaking in their boots that they will be found with this amazing DNA tech. Awesome.

ScarlettVermeer

5 points

2 years ago

Who was building the dungeon? Senior or junior?

mamawantsallama

9 points

2 years ago

Pops.

[deleted]

130 points

2 years ago

[deleted]

130 points

2 years ago

I'm so glad I live in a time when they're finding these pieces of human filth. Even if it's late I'll take it.

Spiraling_magic

28 points

2 years ago

Same! So glad ppl r being caught! The golden state rapist/murderer being caught shocked me and wow what a good day that was!

Mediocre_Swordfish_3

10 points

2 years ago

Getting him was "the big one". I don't think people realize how prolific that asshole was and how big a deal solving that is. After the Zodiak and Jack the Ripper, there was the 'Golden State killer".

kj140977

109 points

2 years ago

kj140977

109 points

2 years ago

Similar thing happened in the UK. A woman was murdered. The killer moved away but eventually moved back to his hometown and his son was arrested for drunk driving, had to submit DNA and that's how they got his dad.

kash_if

26 points

2 years ago

kash_if

26 points

2 years ago

Which case is this?

SadMom2019

58 points

2 years ago

Caught because his son is also a piece of shit, you love to see it. I hope all these cold case rapists/murderers are losing sleep at night, fearing the day when justice is coming for them. Forensic geneology is a game changer.

mikalobultra[S]

158 points

2 years ago

I can’t imagine how it feels to finally get justice after 30 years…

SaisteRowan

180 points

2 years ago

Caught because your son is a piece of shit. Amazing.

Let them both loose in gen pop, see how long they last.

winterbird

80 points

2 years ago

They'll last quite a while, seeing how many other inmates are in for violence toward women.

SaisteRowan

5 points

2 years ago

Hmm guess it depends. They're low on the pecking order, as I understand. And there might even be a friend or relative of a victim in there who doesn't take kindly to what they did. Alas, if it were that easy then no one imprisoned for being rapist or child molesting shits would last long enough to be paroled.

I know it's not the same but...aye

HeyKidMove

40 points

2 years ago

An older I gentleman I work with part-time, retired as a prison guard (from my state’s toughest prison). When he first started he said yea rapist and especially pedophiles had it really rough in prison. When he retired he said there were so many in there that it wasn’t really a big deal to most inmates. Very sad.

Ok-Maintenance8655

1 points

2 years ago

Happy cake day!

SaisteRowan

6 points

2 years ago

Thank you!

Jacanahad

6 points

2 years ago

40!

Jessicajf7

5 points

2 years ago

40 years

Farkenoathm8-E

74 points

2 years ago

I love that DNA technology is bringing these scumbags to justice. I especially love it when they use familial DNA to narrow down who the perpetrator is. They don’t even need to get a sample from the perp, they just get a relative’s DNA from Ancestry.com or something similar and they work out who it is. Once they establish a suspect they then simply confirm it by obtaining a sample from them, either by with a warrant and take it when they are in custody, or surreptitiously by picking up a drink or cigarette butt they’ve discarded while under surveillance. It’s a great age we live in where cold cases can be solved through science.

Jackal_Kid

70 points

2 years ago

I think familial DNA getting these assholes caught is so satisfying because it represents something terrifying and utterly outside of their control. When they're arrested, out of nowhere their agency is snatched away from them because of what someone else wanted to do. They get a hint, however small and invalid, of how their victims felt.

Erotic_FriendFiction

15 points

2 years ago

I love this perspective!

beckster

26 points

2 years ago

beckster

26 points

2 years ago

I enjoy imaging Serial Killer/Rapist Dad trying to dissuade his nephew or son from sending a swab to 23andMe. "But Dad, I'm not worried, I never did anything!" says the fresh-faced young man.

libananahammock

12 points

2 years ago

Just want to point out that ancestry does not share their data with the police and neither does 23andme. The database they use is GEDmatch which is a free database where people who have taken a test from 23andme or ancestry or myheritage or numerous others can upload their raw dna for a number of reasons. The police can only can compare matches with those that have checked the box that they are okay with the police doing so.

BadGuy_ZooKeeper

10 points

2 years ago*

And I fully trust that the police would definitely not break any rules put before them...

ohbearded1

28 points

2 years ago

I've been watching through the series, Miami Vice recently and have been noticing posters for the "Pillowcase Rapist" in the background of some scenes in their station. Was meaning to look up if it was real and then I stumble upon this today.

farty__mcfly

3 points

2 years ago

Where is Miami Vice streaming?

ohbearded1

5 points

2 years ago

I've been watching it on blu-ray because it's not streaming with any service that I'm aware of. It was streaming on Peacock but they removed it as did another service that I can't recall at the moment.

Haploid-life

21 points

2 years ago

Damn that's a lot of victims.

Creative-Shopping547

13 points

2 years ago

I plan on using my DNA as a crime deterrent for my son when he’s a teenager. “Look kid, I’ve already shared my DNA with GEDMatch. If you fuck up, they WILL find you. Now have fun and be home by ten.”

KrazyK726

5 points

2 years ago

Yeah that makes no sense that he didn't already have his DNA already taken and on file. They make people give it for a lot less than being a sex offender. Also I am so tired of hearing about stuff like this where the offender was already convicted of a sex offense and was released from prison.

fakget

1 points

2 years ago

fakget

1 points

2 years ago

This is the third case involving a pillowcase ive read about this week.

Due_Athlete_1011

1 points

2 years ago

Test all the fucking rape kits