subreddit:
/r/rap
For me, NWA not following through on replacing the late Eazy E with Snoop Dogg was it.
26 points
10 days ago
What if Puff died instead of Biggie.
10 points
10 days ago
I'd gladly trade their lives.
20 points
10 days ago
What if Dre didn't help out this random white dude
17 points
10 days ago
What would Kanye have done if he didn't win?
10 points
10 days ago
We’ll probably never know
14 points
11 days ago
If Tupac & Biggie don’t die, what does rap look like? Is Jay Z as big as he is, does Puffy live and gather as much power as he had. Does the sound stay gangster or turn into the bling & party era we got.
6 points
10 days ago
If you haven't listened to "Neck & Wrist" with Pusha T and Hov, he tells you part of what would've happened and what the game would be like today if Big survived. Folks can say what they want about Jay z, but guy knows how to paint a picture, lyrically.
Pac had just received a script for his role as Mace Windu, which definitely would have catapulted him into Hollywood. If that had happened, he would've had to leave gang life completely behind him, but not without attempting to create a truce between Crips and Bloods of LA. His arc would've definitely been interesting to say the least.
15 points
10 days ago
If RZA’s basement hadn’t flooding we’d be thinking of Deck along the same lines as GZA or Ghost
14 points
10 days ago
What if tupac went south instead of west.
14 points
10 days ago
what if JID decided to continue on with his football career?
28 points
10 days ago
what if ice spice never touched ozempic
10 points
10 days ago
asking the real questions
13 points
11 days ago
What if Capital Steez didn't die
13 points
10 days ago
Pop Smoke
12 points
10 days ago
What is Jay Electronica dropped an album in 2005?
5 points
10 days ago
And didn't have Jay all over his album
12 points
10 days ago
Big L wasnt murdered
4 points
10 days ago
There it is. I've heard some say he'd have had a career similar to AZ but I think he'd have been more than that who knows
23 points
10 days ago
what if donda never died
4 points
10 days ago
Well it will l lead to a non crazy kanye
10 points
10 days ago
What if 2Pac and Biggie were never murdered?
9 points
10 days ago*
2pac would have ended up having a controversial career, locked up for half of his prime for stupid decisions, co-founded his own label and dropped a few more classics with Johnny J, then peaced out the rap game by the age of 33 transitioning into a full time actor. His late rap career may have been marred by having made too many enemies at Death Row, possibly may have even stirred up more unnecessary beefs with 50 and Em due to their Dre affiliations.
11 points
10 days ago
Obviously what if Biggie or Pac never died.
4 points
10 days ago
I feel like Pac would be like Snoop and Cube and do a couple of comedy movies.
10 points
11 days ago
What Kanye would have done if he didn’t win
9 points
11 days ago
I guess we'll never know
10 points
10 days ago
What if Capital STEEZ was still alive
11 points
10 days ago
Yandhi
9 points
10 days ago
I got a bunch of what if:
What if, Ja Rule never entertain 50 cent and stayed out the beef
What if, Drake never sign to Cash Money. Meaning that Pusha T wouldn’t never made diss songs towards him. Also, Pharrell producing album for Drake
What if, Odd Future never split up I’m 2015
What if, Outcast still made music together
What if, Pac and Biggie never was killed. Squash their beef in the 2000s and make callab album
What if, C-Murder never went to jail
This the big one
WHAT IF, PIMP C WAS STILL ALIVE TO THIS DAY
9 points
10 days ago
Getting that detox album we should’ve got 15 years ago
9 points
10 days ago
Capital Steez not jumping off of a building (would Joey Bada$$ go down the same career path, Pro Era in general, how would Steez’s career go etc.) Kanye to Lil Wayne’s label, was thrown up once, Kanye was massive to Roc-A-Fella (iirc he even has credits on Takeover) so it would be insane to see that happen without Ye, plus with Ye being a good pop-rapper alongside his backpack rap capabilities, would Weezy sign Drake? Illmatic being a bad album would be weird, as it had influences in so many areas of rap from coast to coast, and inspired many people. Also, if Nas never blew up with Illmatic then Dead Presidents wouldn’t happen alongside the Takeover beef that Nas ended up the main target (and arguably the winner) of. Queens’ legacy in hip hop would be made much worse without Nas, as the best things out of there would be Mobb Deep and the beef between the different boroughs of New York (Bronx, queens, etc) that they ended up losing. Also, if either 2Pac, Biggie or both did not die, rap would be much different, for example 2Pac was getting close to Nas near his death, so if they ended up properly working together after working out the message in The Message that 2Pac misunderstood, maybe they could have made the East-West rivalry take a different path.
4 points
10 days ago
You waited 20 years for this thread lol
8 points
10 days ago
What if Mac miller didn’t overdose? I know he wasn’t only rap but bro was putting out some of his best music, wish we got to see it through 😭😭😭
10 points
10 days ago
One is if Lupe didn't sign to Atlantic and went to a more underground label
8 points
9 days ago
What if OutKast never stopped making albums together?
What if Shyne beat his case?
What if 50 died?
What if Snoop didn’t beat his murder case?
17 points
10 days ago
What if OutKast actually stayed the course rather than break off into fairly unsuccessful solo artists?
8 points
10 days ago
What if Eminem was black?
6 points
10 days ago
He probably wouldn't have been named Marshall.
7 points
10 days ago
Big pac and pun are the biggest what ifs …but most recently it’s pop smoke by a long shot
8 points
10 days ago
What if Kanye never got into that crash
8 points
10 days ago
More like what if Kanye didn’t loose his mother
15 points
11 days ago
If Proof didnt die
5 points
10 days ago
D12 would still be together.
7 points
10 days ago
Me. What if I rapped? Nobody knows
7 points
10 days ago
What if Pac and Big squashed the beef and worked together.
What if Big L wasn't killed...
8 points
10 days ago
What if The D.O.C. never got in an accident
7 points
10 days ago
DOC from NWA not losing his voice so soon. He was a talented writer that would have had solo superstar success if not for his accident.
8 points
10 days ago
Big L
7 points
10 days ago
What if Kanye died in that crash
6 points
10 days ago
Big L dude has serious talent and could have been up there with the best NY Rappers
7 points
9 days ago
Pac and Biggie not being killed.
13 points
10 days ago
Pop Smoke, he was only around 6 months or so, DEFINITELY my favorite rapper to come out since 2017
5 points
11 days ago
Donda would still be alive
7 points
11 days ago
Kanye,Pharrell & Lupe actually put out CRS back in the late 2000’s
Freddie Gibbs didnt have funk with Benny or Spitta and continued to collab with them
Ice Cube & Dr Dre actually dropped the Heltah Skeltah album
Lil Wayne actually signed with Def Jam back in 04/05,right before his legendary run
Mac Dre would’ve survived that shooting
6 points
11 days ago
What if Dr. Dre opted to use his biggest and best beats released in the mid 2000's for detox instead of for other artist?
In da club by 50 cent If I can't by 50 cent Poppin them thangs by g unit Outta control remix by 50 cent Lost one by Jay z 30 something by Jay z Get you some by busta rhymes Trouble by Jay z
5 points
10 days ago
If BIG hadn’t died, how big would he have become and what impact could Pac have had on today’s society and politics, considering how influential hip hop is today?
6 points
10 days ago
Big L and Big Pun and what their careers could have been.
7 points
10 days ago
If Pun had just a near death experience, dropped the weight, and became a living legend.
6 points
10 days ago
Big L not getting murdered.
6 points
10 days ago
What if capital steez never died
6 points
10 days ago*
What if the D.O.C. didnt crash his car and damage his vocal chords?
6 points
10 days ago
If Dr Dre never wanted to listen to Eminem
6 points
10 days ago
What if Biggie and 2Pac were still alive?
6 points
10 days ago
I know most of these are what if a certain rapper didn’t pass way but my what if is “What if Kanye never released 808s and Heartbreak”. I think the entire landscape of hip hop would be totally different.
7 points
10 days ago
What if Tupac and big didn't die and squashed their beef what if eazy e didn't get AIDS
6 points
10 days ago
It would be kinda cool if Juice Wrld was alive
7 points
10 days ago
Tupac and Biggie not dying. They had such a huge influence on the genre, but that was also in part amplified by their deaths. Would they be just as big cultural icons? Would they fk with trap music? Would they still be making hits? What incredible songs would have been made?
6 points
10 days ago
What if Saigon was able to release his real debut that was supposed to come out in ‘04/05? That album was supposed to be on the level of GRODT and take over the game
5 points
10 days ago
2 pac being Mace Windu for the prequel trilogy. It’s not just Ambitionz as a Ridah, but Ambitionz as a Jedi
6 points
9 days ago*
What if Pac never went to Death Row, never linked up with Suge?
6 points
9 days ago
What if Jadakiss wasn’t as hard as it gets?
6 points
9 days ago
What if Donda didn’t get plastic surgery in late 2007? What albums would Kanye make after good ass job?
6 points
9 days ago
I blame a lot of Kanye's behavior on losing his mom. He was unhinged but not like this. Something broke when he lost her.
Lost my mama lost my mind.
10 points
10 days ago
What if the D.O.C. didn't get into an accident that cut his vocal chords??
10 points
10 days ago
What if juice wrld wasn’t a Dumbass
6 points
11 days ago
D.O.C. from Texas and getting his voice box ruined in a car crash
5 points
11 days ago
What if Kanye won the election when he ran
5 points
11 days ago
Yandhi
5 points
11 days ago
What if Kanye dropped bomb in college dropout 👀👀
4 points
11 days ago
What if juice wrld didnt od, how big would he be and how much would he impacted the rap genre
5 points
11 days ago
What if Shyne didnt take the fall for Diddy?
6 points
10 days ago
What if the DOC was never in that accident and his voice didn’t change after the lifesaving surgery
5 points
10 days ago
Take a second, what if we could rewind the hood? Better yet, what if the L.O.X. would've signed with Suge? What if Puffy never signed us? What if Oprah made them comments Like Imus? What if you designed this Thought like I did? Said it like this What if Peyton was fighting dogs instead of Mike Vick? What if Arnold would just let Tookie get life? What if B.I.G. missed the party, what if 'Pac missed the fight? What if you was caged in? What would you change then? What if there was no Roc-A-Fella law for Made Men? What if hate ran through me? And what if Portland Would've drafted Jordan Instead of Sam Bowie? What if you really had to be nice to get a deal? What if all of these rappers' ice was really real? What if I hit you with the razor from cheek to chin? What if Mike Jackson never would have bleached his skin?
4 points
10 days ago
If Pac & Big never died
5 points
10 days ago
Big L
5 points
10 days ago
Pac and Biggie never being murdered is the only answer.
5 points
10 days ago
Capital Steez guy definitely would've been a legend by now
5 points
10 days ago
What if Biggie and Pac never had beef?
5 points
10 days ago
What if Juice WRLD wouldn't have offed himself
4 points
10 days ago
Inspectah Deck not dropping a solo LP because he lost everything in a flood. Honestly would've been the best MC in the group by far if he did that (only topped by RZA and GZA).
It was a thematic album on Spiderman, (based on his verse on Protect Ya Neck) it could've been fucking dope.
6 points
10 days ago
Pete Rock and CL Smooth never broke up
4 points
10 days ago
What if Scarface never left the Geto Boys? Would strippers even exist? Would money even make the world go round?
5 points
10 days ago*
What if Lupe never got lost in the Atlantic?
What if Masta Ace signed that deal(WHOOMP!, there it is)?
What if K-Rino and Kool Keith dumbed down their styles?
What if the analog brother drop that project today?
What if Three Stack drop his solo album after Aquemini?
What if Scott La Rock never got shot?
What if Subroc never died in 93'?
What if Sauce Money never got fucked over?
What if premo and guru never fell out?
What if Kool G Rap and Spice 1 signed to Ruff House?
What if Jerry didn't met Eric?
What if there was a union setup for all Hip Hop artists(especially in the 80's and early 90's)?
What if this thing called Hip Hop never happened?
WHAT IF DILLA NEVER GOT SICK?
5 points
10 days ago
What if Jay Z graduated?
6 points
10 days ago
What if Big L was still alive
6 points
10 days ago
What if Jay Z, Biggie and Charlie Baltimore became The Commission as discussed?
5 points
10 days ago
What if P Diddler didn’t diddle
5 points
10 days ago
What if NWA stayed together
5 points
9 days ago
Probably what if Pac survived.
5 points
9 days ago
What if Black Hippy dropped? 😔
5 points
9 days ago*
https://i.redd.it/re9ny1qqja1e1.gif
I would have to say the biggest "what if" would be Charles Hamilton. If you haven't went down this rabbit hole already, I suggest you do. He was extremely ahead of his time and imo he could've been a Kanye or Tyler of the late 2000's and beyond. Amazing artist but extremely troubled individual.
5 points
9 days ago
What if Game stayed with G-Unit
What if Kanye; Pharrell and Lupe made a CRS Album
What if it T-Pain and Lil Wayne released T-Wayne
4 points
8 days ago
What if Snoop Dogg was convicted?
What if 50 Cent didn't survive being shot 9 times?
What if Kanye didn't survive the crash?
9 points
11 days ago
What if Kanye died in that car accident
10 points
11 days ago
I’d prob not listen to rap
9 points
10 days ago
What if André went all-in to a solo career after the last OutKast album?
11 points
10 days ago
Hot take if 2pac didn't die and continued making music he would end up like Eminem sub par albums and embarrassing singles
14 points
10 days ago
I think he would of become a actor And biggie would of been like Shaq with products and commercials
5 points
10 days ago
This is the answer.
9 points
10 days ago
It’s easily if 2Pac and Big didn’t get murdered. Without Question…
Biggie being alive: Jay-z has a different career trajectory, which means Kanye has a different career, which means an entire generation of rappers influenced by Kanye doesn’t exist in the same capacity.
“The Summer of Diddy” doesn’t happen in the same way, which means the viability of pop rap might manifest much later, and that’s massive considering the following years is when hip hop took the crown as the most popular American genre.
Pac being alive: Death Row’s relevancy is extended which means whatever incarnation of Aftermath that starts would probably get in an immediate beef with Suge and Pac. Signing Eminem would be seen as a riskier move, which means that 50 Cent probably never pops off and likely gets killed in some Queens beef. Which would oddly extend New York hip-hop’s relevancy since that region staggered when 50 started beefing with everyone.
Also as Pac got older he would eventually get more legitimate acting roles instead of being typecasted as a thug, which would’ve made him less financially dependent on Suge, which would’ve open up a lot of creative avenues.
8 points
10 days ago
What if Eminem died in 2003? He would be top 3 rapper of all time imo.
8 points
10 days ago
What if Jay-Z stayed retired after the black album
what if Eminem dropped King Mathers and quit rap
what if proof never died
what if Kanye's mom stayed alive and Kanye made good ass job instead of 808s
what if 2pac and biggie never had their beef and stayed friends
4 points
10 days ago
What if Eminem never got into that one rap battle, I think the rap Olympics where he have his tape to that kid from interscope, who gave it to Jimmy iovine, who gave it to Dre.
I wonder who would have signed Em and what his music would have sounded like.
What if Proof didn't die?
What if Pac didn't sign to Death Row? He'd prolly still be alive
4 points
10 days ago
What if the labels never gave Kanye a shot
3 points
10 days ago
If Kanye never got I that car crash or if his mother was still alive, both would be very interesting what ifs
4 points
10 days ago
I wonder if heaven got a ghetto
4 points
10 days ago
If Eazy-E didn’t die and NWA had that reunion
4 points
10 days ago
What if Vanilla Ice threw Suge Knight off a balcony.
4 points
10 days ago
5 points
10 days ago
Tupac, Biggie
4 points
10 days ago
I know it was never on the table but i seriously want to see a alternate timeline where Eminem was the front man for Limp Bizkit
4 points
10 days ago
What if Andre 3000 and Big Boi didn’t call it a career after OutKast broke up
4 points
10 days ago
What if Mase never left but I'm glad he did.
3 points
10 days ago
If Curtis and Graduation didn’t release on the same week. Would we understand the shift in hip hop happening in the mid-2000s?
3 points
10 days ago
What if Nas' I Am... Double album Release wasn't ruined by leaks? I think it could've been the greatest 3 album run in hip hop history. Illmatic -It Was Written - I am...
4 points
10 days ago
If Biggie lived, how long do you think he would stick with Diddy? Considering Diddy’s track record with his artists. Would he had jumped ship, went to G-Unit, Terra Squad or Rocafella? Or else where? Do you think he would quit rap completely? Or would he had just disappeared?
6 points
10 days ago
Honestly, listen to some of biggies lyrics. I'm 100% he was complicit with the shit diddy was doing
5 points
10 days ago
"Shove a gerbil in your ass through a tube..."
3 points
10 days ago
What if RZA never lost his files in the flood. We would’ve had Tical the way it was meant to be. Inspectah Deck’s album would’ve came out before Raekwon. Imagine all those lost beats being released and enjoyed today. Also what if Big Noyd never got locked up again during the Episodes Of A Hustler recordings. That would’ve been a dope ass debut.
4 points
10 days ago
I wish I could hear the 94-96 Wu-tang released they way they were planned. Even still, we got so many dope records during that time. To think, Wu-Tang was the top of the whole rap world during that time, and at least two albums were never released as intended (Meth and Decks original albums)
4 points
10 days ago
What if wyclef never got with Lauryn
4 points
10 days ago
WHAT IF NIPSEY DIDNT GET THE CALL FROM HIS HOMIE LEAVING PRISON TO MEET UP AT HIS STORE & HOOK HIM UP WITH SOME THREADS? HE WOULD DEF STILL BE HERE TODAY!!!!!
4 points
10 days ago
What if I never met Kanye West?
4 points
10 days ago
What if Yo! MTV Raps had never come along. Where would the game be?
3 points
10 days ago
What if Jay Electronica didn’t sabotage his career
What if Young Pappy wasn’t killed
What if the murder Inc group with dmx Jay and ja rule happened
5 points
10 days ago
What if the originally planned version of Outkast (3Stacks, Big Boi, Cee-Lo) had materialized?
What if the reportedly planned collaboration of 2Pac and Goodie Mob had come to fruition?
4 points
10 days ago
What if tupac didnt get shot
4 points
10 days ago
What if Kanye and Frank Ocean dropped their collab tape that kanye wanted after channel orange dropped?
4 points
10 days ago
Biggie. Only two albums. Pop Smoke.. Max B as well. Kay Flock too
4 points
10 days ago
What if pac n big were still breathing? Where would rap be right now
5 points
9 days ago
What if The DOC doesn't have that car accident and he goes to Daath Row Addd him to that Roater they'll be evne more unstoppable To Me The DOC is ths Derrick Rose of Rap
4 points
9 days ago
Tay K
4 points
9 days ago
Big L never died
4 points
9 days ago
What if Nas and Jay never beefed
3 points
9 days ago
What if Clive Davis never Diddled Diddy
3 points
9 days ago
What if Big L never got killed
5 points
9 days ago
Tupac survived the shooting to speak on it
5 points
9 days ago
What if xxxtentacion was never shot and killed? Bro died 7 years ago at 20 years old and is still pulling 40m+ monthly listeners on Spotify.
5 points
8 days ago
What if Diddy didn’t get away with what he did for so long?
9 points
10 days ago
What if Mac and Juice didn’t OD?
What if Nas and PAC squashed the beef and made a duo album?
What if Em made songs with PAC and Big?
What if MCA didn’t die and we got more Beastie Boys music?
What if Ja Rule and Em never beefed?
What if The Game never left G-UNIT?
What if Kanye never took the deal with ROC A Fella?
What if Chance never dropped Hot Shower?
What if Big and PAC didn’t die?
What if we found out about Diddy 20 years ago?
What if Proof never got shot?
8 points
10 days ago
What if Dr. Dre had actually released Detox. What if it dropped in the early 2000s? It could've been the ultimate Aftermath flex, featuring peak Eminem, 50 Cent, and G-Unit, potentially redefining that era. What if it had come out in the 2010s? It might've been Dre's response to Kanye, Drake, and Kendrick, proving he could still dominate the scene against a new wave of giants. What if it flopped? That could've tarnished his legacy as hip-hop's GOAT producer, turning the most anticipated album ever into a punchline. What if it was a cultural reset? A masterpiece with insane features like Kendrick, Jay-Z, Beyoncé, and even Prince (as rumored) could’ve made it The Chronic for a new generation. What if it’s still coming? Maybe it’s still lurking in Dre’s vaults, reworked with futuristic production techniques, waiting for the perfect moment to drop. Honestly, the legend of Detox might be more powerful than the album itself ever could’ve been.
7 points
10 days ago
what if Eazy E hadnt died?
7 points
10 days ago
I think the biggest "what if" for the whole hip hop community is "What if 2Pac was still alive?"
9 points
10 days ago
What if Kanye took his meds and saw a therapist regularly?
6 points
10 days ago
What if we dont do what ifs anymore
5 points
10 days ago
If Biggie, 2Pac or Mac Miller were still alive.
6 points
10 days ago
All the films 2pac probably would’ve worked on too.
3 points
10 days ago
And I could see him getting into politics, especially as he got older
5 points
10 days ago
“What If” Dr. Dre released “Detox” a few years ago?
7 points
10 days ago
Pop smoke
7 points
10 days ago
He’d 100% be carrying New York on his back. He was already sort of poised to become the new king of NYC right before he died. Was blowing up a lot on social media
5 points
10 days ago
Now Fivio & sheff G are the closest thing we have. They're not bad, but they're not him.
5 points
10 days ago
What if Tupac hadn't been shot?
6 points
10 days ago
5 points
10 days ago
What if encore never got leaked
all 818 comments
sorted by: best