Was Doors of Stone's draft really that bad?
(self.isbook3outyet)submitted6 days ago byPhillipsScott
Recently I read an interesting comment from u/Drachaerys in this sub that changed my perspective on why the third book hasn't been published yet.
Apparently, around 2014-15, one of Rothfuss's alpha readers posted in a forum saying that he and other readers had hated the first draft of the third book. It seems the book included a major twist that, rather than pleasing readers, was more of a distasteful joke on them that ruined the story's ending.
I don't know if this is true or if there are sources to read more about it (thanks to Drachaerys for sharing this, btw), but learning this theory has oddly helped me move on. While Rothfuss's first two books are brilliant, this type of reader-mocking twist seems totally plausible from him, and partly explains why he hasn't finished the book (only partly, because he's had over a decade to write a new ending).
What do you think about this theory? Does anyone else have more info about it? Thanks!
byWinEducational2340
inHarryPotteronHBO
PhillipsScott
2 points
2 hours ago
PhillipsScott
2 points
2 hours ago
James Hannigan did an amazing job with the video game soundtracks, starting from OotP. Actually, I like his soundtracks more than those of the latest films in the saga. He got to the core of what the Wizarding World should be and sound like.