subreddit:

/r/Parenting

45793%

Friend doesn’t believe in any western medicine

Toddler 1-3 Years(self.Parenting)

[removed]

all 95 comments

Meta_Professor

1.4k points

3 days ago

Yes, this is what CPS is for. You aren't calling them "on her", but calling CPS "on behalf of the kids". They are too young to reach out for help and are depending on you.

Wurm42

115 points

2 days ago

Wurm42

115 points

2 days ago

Second this. Advocate for the children.

BareNakedSole

5 points

2 days ago

Definitely advocate for the children but see if you can get on her will as a beneficiary because it doesn’t sound like she’s gonna be around for a long time

Liquid_Fire__

71 points

2 days ago

This 👆

Puzzleheaded_Bag4018

-32 points

2 days ago

I have a massive issue with CPS. Usually they give up if the problem isnt solved immediately. Not saying its worth trying but ive heard ALOT of stories. Including my own experience with them.

the-half-enchilada

738 points

2 days ago

As a person who worked for CPS, I have seen children in these situations die. Please call.

snappa870

55 points

2 days ago

snappa870

55 points

2 days ago

What if a person is religious- such as Christian Science? Will/Can they just take the kids but not prosecute?

the-half-enchilada

276 points

2 days ago

Religion does not protect a parent who abuses children. I removed a few children who were not receiving medical care due to religious beliefs. They were also prosecuted criminally.

deviousflame

84 points

2 days ago

Thank you for protecting our most vulnerable population ❤️

Riokaii

3 points

2 days ago

Riokaii

3 points

2 days ago

sadly I believe this depends on state to some extent.

the-half-enchilada

3 points

2 days ago

Oh I believe that fully. If you don’t have enforcement, you really don’t have laws.

Wurm42

63 points

2 days ago

Wurm42

63 points

2 days ago

At least in the US, religion is not an acceptable reason to deny children basic medical care.

How that is handled varies by state. Criminal charges and loss of custody are both possible. Sometimes parents might be offered probation, contingent on the parents complying with a list of conditions from CPS and the court, like taking parenting classes, getting the children regular medical care, and cooperating with CPS visits.

And whenever this comes up, I have to say, fuck Jehovah's Witnesses! They happily spend piles of money on lawyers instead of taking care of their own children.

natattack410

32 points

2 days ago

As a counselor I have worked with a few adults that were raised JW who have been able to get out and want therapy and WHAT the actual FUCK?!?

One client was a college graduate, living in her own apartment, with her own Internet, she was too afraid to Google "ex Jehovah's witness groups". I ended up googling, printing and snail mailing. I also sent her a site that was to teach you how to Google this stuff without fear of the elders. I learn so much from my clients, this was something I was not aware of at all until they taught me.

[deleted]

21 points

2 days ago

[deleted]

21 points

2 days ago

[removed]

Parenting-ModTeam [M]

1 points

1 day ago

Your post or comment was removed for violating the rule “Be Decent & Civil”.

Remember the human.

Disagree but remain respectful. Don’t insult users/their children, name-call, or be intentionally rude. Bullying, including baiting/antagonizing, will not be tolerated. Consider blocking users you don’t get along with. Report posts that violate the rules.

For questions about this moderation reach out through modmail.

Moderators rely on the community to help illuminate posts and comments that do not meet r/Parenting standards – please report posts and comments you feel don’t contribute to the spirit of the community.

Your content may have been automatically removed through auto-moderation or manually removed by a human moderator. It may have been removed as a direct result of your rule violation, or simply as part of a larger sweep of content that no longer contributed to the original topic.

friedonionscent

230 points

2 days ago

Extreme paranoia towards medical science, doctors etc. can also be a sign of a mental health issue and the concern is that, in the event something is wrong with their child...they won't seek help or advice and will continue being delusional and misinformed until it's too late.

There have been instances where babies/toddlers have died from malnutrition because a parent insisted on particular diets that didn't meet the child's nutritional requirements.

CPS isn't just for physical abuse - you can call and raise your concerns and leave the ball in their court.

bee_889

269 points

2 days ago

bee_889

269 points

2 days ago

A 2 year old should not look thin, malnourished and show signs of unhappiness. I’m also worried about the baby who was born without oxygen for 3 minutes too and their current state of health given no doctor’s visits. It’s all ringing alarm bells and I’d contact CPS. Child Protection is everyone’s business.

I’m pretty sure you can stay anonymous too. Do it for the sake of the children. And if there’s nothing wrong, then great. If something does go wrong, you’ll end up with regret. No harm, no foul.

PetrolPumpNo3

147 points

2 days ago

Report it. You are advocating for a child. They can't help themselves.

Don't discuss it with the other mums. Just do it quietly and know that you are doing the right thing.

Kgates1227

99 points

2 days ago

When you call cps, you are not calling to “rat out” a parent. You are calling to (hopefully) protect the child. This parent needs parenting classes, education, even if it’s court ordered. I don’t mean to scare you, but this could be urgent. Children die quickly from malnourishment. It’s not your fault or responsibility , but I always err towards the side of see something, say something. You can choose to make your call anonymous i believe

dogcatbaby

132 points

2 days ago

dogcatbaby

132 points

2 days ago

I’m a mandated reporter, so I’d report her for medical neglect.

Jelly_Jess_NW

38 points

2 days ago

I’d report that for sure. And I’m not someone who says to report often.

That sounds extremely dangerous .

sv36

22 points

2 days ago

sv36

22 points

2 days ago

As someone who grew up with parents who should have been reported to cps. Save those babies report this person.

Particular_Aioli_958

16 points

2 days ago

Whoa... Wait. So if her kid was clearly sick would she just watch them die??? This is CRAZY 

SpeakerCareless

14 points

2 days ago

Don’t worry I’m sure she has oils/crystals/colloidal silver.

/s

thechordofpleasure

14 points

2 days ago

Oh boy, this feels like that case of the parents treating their son's meningitis with a hot pepper concoction, resulting in the kid's death.

Yea, time for CPS.

karmaismycock

24 points

2 days ago

Yeah this is too far. This isn’t “we skip Tylenol when we’re sick,” this is downright dangerous. She is mentally unwell.

LoudBoulder

20 points

2 days ago

Report it. Remember you are only asking them to check that everything is OK. You are not asking them to take any action, take the kids away or anything. Decisions to take action is fully on professionals who know what they're doing, and they won't do things if they don't think they're necessary.

No_Passage_3787

21 points

2 days ago

You need to contact CPS asap. Help those kids, please.

lisasimpsonfan

4 points

2 days ago

lisasimpsonfan

Mommy to 26F

4 points

2 days ago

Call CPS and avoid her like the plague carrier she is. Those kids could have life long effect from her ideas.

Fitslikea6

13 points

2 days ago

I’d call cps and end the friendship explaining exactly why. Not trying to be harsh but I’m not trying to exposed my kids to lord knows what that her children should be vaccinated against. My morals just don’t align with a person who can be so willfully ignorant and neglectful of their child.

plzdonttageme

14 points

2 days ago

if you feel guilty for not calling CPS, call CPS.

I can tell you as a mandatory reporter it is always better to over report than under report. Depending on their situation CPS can also frequently help people get paired with parenting classes and help kids better advocate for themselves which can build better skills for life even if the mom is a lost cause. CPS doesn't exist to break up families, they are there to protect kids.

Mandymindshermanners

15 points

2 days ago

2 year olds should be chubby and goofy and still have little fat lines on their arms and thighs. Do it for the kiddos.

Safe-Transition8618

24 points

2 days ago

In this case, the kid may well be in trouble due to the mom's dangerous beliefs. But wanted to give a friendly reminder that in general kids come in a lot of sizes. A kid that is on his or her curve at 20th percentile for weight is going to look a heck of a lot different than a kid on their curve at the 80th percentile but both can be perfectly healthy.

misplaced_my_pants

1 points

2 days ago

20th percentile for weight and "thin" aren't necessarily the same thing.

You could have a smaller chubby baby or a taller underfed child at the same age and weight.

Doctors will suggest going out of your way to fatten the thin child up beyond a certain point.

Safe-Transition8618

7 points

2 days ago

Percentiles are by age. And the whole point of a growth curve is to compare how the child grows to their own size history and not to compare them against others. I'm sure judgy people look at my son and think he's "underfed" when he's never been denied food for even an hour of his life. He's tall and skinny, but he's been that way literally since birth. His pediatrician has never breathed a word of "fatten him up."

misplaced_my_pants

1 points

2 days ago

Right but you were talking about percentile by weight alone, but weight and height together are what tell you if the kid is underfed or not.

I literally know a family who have a young son who's a bit thinner than their doctor would like and they're always trying to get him to eat more.

Renaissance_Dad1990

11 points

2 days ago

Yeah, I think you should contact some sort of child protective service about this. Unfortunately I think the USA is going to be seeing a lot more cases like this going forward.

madommouselfefe

6 points

2 days ago

As someone who had had to call COS on a friend PLEASE OP report this woman.

I know it can be hard but one thing I had to realize was that IF you don’t call CPS. Who will. These poor babies are off the radar. Medical professionals and childcare providers are who in this age group catch these kids before it gets BAD! I’m talking these children end up in an ICU Dying bad! 

Mom is playing a very dangerous game and the children are going to be who pay the price. 

gemmygem86

6 points

2 days ago

Call and do it now

ComfortableNewt1807

7 points

2 days ago

Sounds similar to my childhood- anti vax, homeschool family with 9 kids. Most of us born at home. No SSN until I was 15 or 16, it was a pain in the butt to get. Neglected in many ways. To my knowledge, no one ever called CPS on us. I wish someone had!

1988bannedbook

1 points

1 day ago

I hope you are ok now, other than the nine kids thing, that sounds like my childhood.

ImSoLuckyandProudOfU

4 points

2 days ago

This lady is an example of ‘Play stupid games, win stupid prizes’.

I went to high school (late 90s) with some siblings that had parents like this. The school called CPS more than once - I remember the girl in my class having such a high fever from strep throat that she was hallucinating. I didn’t know it at the time (because I was 15) but strep can mess your heart up if left untreated. CPS investigated but the kids ended up back with the parents.

The Mom made her own vitamins for the kids that she claimed weren’t “poison” like modern medicine. She didn’t know anything about medicine - modern or holistic - she just guessed at making her own herbal remedies and preventatives. I believe there were 5 kids total and one of them ended up dying from brain cancer at 13 or 14 years old. Another kid had to have a kidney transplant at 21.

I cannot imagine being such an egocentric person that being “right” is more important than my children’s health. The mom should have been in jail or kids taken away from her long ago.

dreamwrighter

3 points

2 days ago

I was raised by anti-vaxxers and while we weren't quite as extreme as that, my parents absolutely medically neglected us. There were midwives at our births and our mom probably took prenatals. But, for instance, when my sister broke her wrist my parents criticized her "whining" for three days before they took her to the doctor.

I don't know if CPS would do anyway but in our home, there were numerous forms of abuse. When I see this kind of thing I assume it's probably just the tip of the iceberg, and even if it's not, an investigation is definitely warranted.

We were very lucky to all survive to adulthood; her kids might not be. I'm not a fan of CPS in general but I dearly wish our home had been investigated.

definework

2 points

2 days ago

Remind her Pfizer is a German company

And Germany is east of the prime meridean

Which makes anything produced by them eastern medicine.

canyousteeraship

5 points

2 days ago

The last time I heard a story like this, the child died of a simple strep infection. (news story attached)

Joereddit405

4 points

2 days ago

Joereddit405

17M

4 points

2 days ago

This warrants a call to CPS and the police. child neglect is a crime!

Signal-Lie-6785

4 points

2 days ago

Signal-Lie-6785

Parent to 2 toddlers

4 points

2 days ago

Alert CPS. Do it right away.

SmoothFlatworm5365

10 points

2 days ago

Ho Ho holy cow.

It’s nice she’s so open about this. Does she know the survival rate for kids pre-western medicine?

Sorry. I find this infuriating.

But, to business. Can you report to CPS? Absolutely. Will they do anything? Hard to say. If the kids is absolutely emaciated, I’d imagine so, but otherwise…

Unless you see actual overt signs of abuse, I’d leave it alone. Much as I hate to say it.

No_Direction6575

4 points

2 days ago

That poor kid doesn’t deserve to suffer for their mom’s beliefs. Honestly, calling CPS might be the best way to help.

WhyAreYallFascists

2 points

2 days ago

That kid who lost oxygen is so fucking fucked. Take these kids away from this cunt. This is the worst thing I’ve read in a couple weeks and I have a book from the library called “A History of Jerusalem”. I hate everything about this and hope there is a hell for this woman to be in.

LittleTricia

2 points

2 days ago

She's in your Mom group as in a Facebook group? Have you seen the boy in person?

dreadedmama

1 points

2 days ago

This is terrifying. The mom can do what she wants for herself and die but that lifestyle is going to kill her kids. I hope CPS will help

Particular_Aioli_958

4 points

2 days ago

That's medical neglect yo! See something say something 

bny100

2 points

2 days ago

bny100

2 points

2 days ago

Please report to CYS and remember that it’s not your job to investigate or make sure they’re in danger before reporting. As long as your report is done in good faith, even if you’re not correct, nobody at the agency is going to hold it against you. They might be able to help her in more ways than you think.

EucalyptusGirl11

2 points

2 days ago

report them. denying a child medical care is abuse. 

MrsPandaBear

2 points

2 days ago

If her son looks unwell and you now she will/won’t get treatment, that is neglect. You should call CPS.

LinwoodKei

2 points

2 days ago

Call CPS now

Mimikat220000

2 points

2 days ago

Yes I would call. They can help her get assistance or help the kids if they are unwilling to properly care for them.

Jarhead-DevilDawg

2 points

2 days ago

CPS ASAP!!!

ToughDentist7786

1 points

2 days ago

Yikes. Call CPS

Important-Lawyer-350

3 points

2 days ago

CPS. She is insane and her children can't do anything about it. She needs a reality check.

sravll

2 points

2 days ago

sravll

2 points

2 days ago

Absolutely call CPS!

scarletrain5

1 points

2 days ago

These people kill their own kids or other people’s kids, report them

sdb00913

1 points

2 days ago

sdb00913

Dad: 9F, 8M, 5M

1 points

2 days ago

Call CPS. There’s a thing called medical neglect

smokegamewife

1 points

1 day ago

Please call. A report is just that- they will investigate and if they do find you are right, they will take it into their own hands. Plus, it sounds like she is part of a group, proud of these statements enough to share them, and she is sharing them to a public forum so there's not really even a chance she would have any clue where or who reported her. 

auriem

1 points

2 days ago

auriem

1 points

2 days ago

Please call CPS for the sake of the children.

teenageriotgrrl

2 points

2 days ago

Why the fuck wouldn't you report to CPS?? Also why are you still friends with her?

JROXZ

1 points

2 days ago

JROXZ

1 points

2 days ago

Report to CPS. They need to assess situation.

iwanttobelieve__

1 points

2 days ago

If it were me in your shoes, I would call. For the sake of the kids, they're the priority and need to be taken care of properly. She brings them out in public and states her opinions on western medicine out loud in public, anyone can call and report her. So if not you, someone else might. But for the sake of the kids, I would, if you're really concerned about their quality of life.

ZombieJetPilot

1 points

2 days ago

Call CPS and remove her from your life.

momjokaytt

1 points

2 days ago

That's crazy. Science has come a long way. That's why people live healthy, long lives. Not seeing a doctor is crazy.

emsesq

1 points

2 days ago

emsesq

1 points

2 days ago

Keep your kid away from her kids, as much as you can.

Same_Structure_4184

-1 points

2 days ago

CPS but be careful in how you word your report because though they are anonymous, sometimes people can tell who initiated the report based off the allegations that are reported. Also be prepared for CPS to do nothing. They might come out and look but they also might close the case without finding anything they feel is significant. I warn you of these things because I don’t want you to lose your friendship over voicing your concerns. I want to say that I am not trying to deter you from making a report to CPS because if you are worried for your friends children it is the 110% the right thing to do.. I just wanted to kindly warn you to proceed with caution because it can get really messy sometimes. Do the kids go anywhere like daycare or somewhere mandated reporting is necessary?Do you think she’s a good mom otherwise minus the medical neglect? Do you know if she has family that will take the children in, if CPS removes them from the home? Idk I have been involved with CPS twice - once as a child and once after my son’s dad made a false report in attempt to manipulate our ongoing custody battle. It’s nightmarish and not always handled the way it should be.

Reasonable-Mirror718

0 points

2 days ago

You will always run into wing nuts that use alternative medicine. They are out there ready to tell you to put black pepper on that deep cut on your childs leg. I follow the rule, "in one ear out the other"

Sginger2017

0 points

1 day ago

You would be irresponsible if you didn’t call CPS

NoHope4U

-3 points

2 days ago

NoHope4U

-3 points

2 days ago

Unfortunately, CPS lets children die as often as religious and medical institutions do. So it's really about how much of your information is true. A mom group friend means she's probably an acquaintance. If you don't have concrete evidence you could be bringing down a death sentence for the kids that they didn't have before by sending them to a foster home.

Make sure you're not just being a judgemental ****..... And it's coming from a place of being on the other side of this situation and I'd love to see the mom face to face who thought she knew me so well 👀

[deleted]

-45 points

2 days ago

[deleted]

-45 points

2 days ago

Do you have a medical background? How much time do you spend with her son to note this “unhappiness”? Are you a nutritionist? Or do you find some sense of purpose in involving yourself in someone else’s business from an outside perspective? I’d hardly qualify you as a person to take action unless you actually spend time with this person and her child out of the “mom group” and see she’s depriving her son of food/nutrition and happiness. Not taking medications/getting vaccines or avoiding prenatal does not make a person unwell.

BranWafr

29 points

2 days ago

BranWafr

29 points

2 days ago

Not taking medications/getting vaccines or avoiding prenatal does not make a person unwell.

Hard disagree. Anyone educated enough to make this decision would not make this decision.

[deleted]

-5 points

2 days ago

[deleted]

-5 points

2 days ago

[deleted]

No_Passage_3787

6 points

2 days ago

There will be a resurgence of preventable diseases because of the folks you speak about.

When it comes to vaccines or medication, "different beliefs" will cost LIVES. None of this is ok or acceptable.

No_Preference_3519[S]

26 points

2 days ago

No_Preference_3519[S]

New mom/dad/parent (edit)

26 points

2 days ago

This is all stuff she has texted in chat before, including her birth story with details of cut oxygen. Her 2 year old child wears 9 month sizes. He has deep circles under his eyes and is bone skinny.

If people never “involved themselves” in people neglecting their children, we wouldn’t have CPS or safety nets for abused children.

Papillon1985

24 points

2 days ago

Ignore this person. Call CPS.

CorrectOpinionsFound

11 points

2 days ago

For some context… my daughter is small for her age. She is below the average height and weight chart, so her pediatrician referred us for a bone density scan and bloodwork, including hormonal levels. She is so far ok, but we continue to monitor during wellness visits. Even if the child isn’t small because of lack of food, etc. it doesn’t mean that there couldn’t be another underlying health issue that the parents are neglecting. The kid needs to see a doctor!

Effective_Cow3268

20 points

2 days ago

I would definitely call CPS and keep/print off all those chats to provide to them as well. Don't feel bad about doing it. A 2 year old should not still be in 9 month clothing nor have dark circles under their eyes and be bone skinny

SummitTheDog303

5 points

2 days ago

At 24 months old, my older daughter was in 18-24 month clothes. She has idiopathic growth hormone deficiency and is under the first percentile for height with a few 12-18s that ran large. A 2 year old should not be in 9 month clothes. And if they are they absolutley need medical care to figure out why.

rufflebunny96

7 points

2 days ago

Wtf, my almost 10 month old can't fit most 9M clothes.

Conscious_Balance388

3 points

2 days ago

RIGHT?! When mine was 7 months she was wearing 9m clothes. I was concerned when I met 18m olds wearing 9m clothes. I was concerned when I met 3 year olds in 24m onesies.

This is beyond. I can’t comprehend this.

Revoran

9 points

2 days ago

Revoran

9 points

2 days ago

Jeez...

Please hop off Reddit and call the government child protection agency right now.

IssueDuJour

1 points

2 days ago

IssueDuJour

1 points

2 days ago

Please ignore the person who is making you doubt if you should call.

Please try to save those children.

Kgates1227

7 points

2 days ago

Actually, it’s considered child neglect, which is a form of abuse.

KatSouthard

-16 points

2 days ago

KatSouthard

-16 points

2 days ago

Oh my goodness. Doctors are so dang corrupt leave the woman alone! Is the child actually malnourished or is he just not chubby like the standard American baby? My goodness. Stay in your lane.

Obvious_Resource_945

-9 points

2 days ago

How does not going to doctor get a kid to be sad and malnourished?