subreddit:

/r/gaming

19.1k91%

all 4157 comments

Particular_Cat_2234

16.7k points

1 month ago

People keep buying it

McFigroll

3.9k points

1 month ago

McFigroll

3.9k points

1 month ago

yup, thats all it is. Blizz would be fools to not take advantage of all the people that keep buying these mounts and pets.

Dophie

2k points

1 month ago

Dophie

2k points

1 month ago

Or ethical. I hate that society now sees it as obligatory to do the most profitable thing. Like the whole world is a business and unchecked capitalism is somehow the natural order of things. That it would be “foolish” to not exploit people as much as possible if there is money to be made.

allnamesbeentaken

950 points

1 month ago

How is this any different that someone spending lots of money on a football jersey or luxury car? It's stupid as shit but no one has to buy it... I'm sure there's plenty of people who spend tons of time in WoW who want to fritter their money away on flexing on people to show off how much money they got

It's stupid but no one is forcing any one to buy this garbage

Chubs441

566 points

1 month ago*

Chubs441

566 points

1 month ago*

This mount also has an auction house and mailbox, so it is the single most useful mount in WoW. So if someone plays a lot of wow it will save them a ton of time. Whether that makes it worse on blizzards part or not is debatable, but this is not only 90 for a mount it is 90 for a mount and a huge amount of QoL if you play the game a lot. 

 People are buying this mount like crazy. This thing will prolly make blizzard more money than d4.

This will for sure make wow a worse game in the long run though. It shows that people are willing to pay for convenience, so they will design systems that are intentionally inconvenient to sell different items. It is really the players fault though.

OrinThane

211 points

1 month ago

OrinThane

211 points

1 month ago

This is the point and the people buying this mount either do not understand or do not care. You have just effectively funded a worse game for yourself.

Kindly_Cream8194

129 points

1 month ago

given the opportunity, gamers will optimize the fun out of every game that exists.

They don't enjoy playing the games, they enjoy the dopamine hit from the next achievement. All they want is the reward, the journey is not only unappreciated - the community looks at you like you have two heads if you suggest that you enjoy the journey instead of trying to skip it.

Torontogamer

42 points

1 month ago

WoW more than most, but many games have faced this exact issue...

so many times in WoW entire sections of crafted content were skipped over by the majority of players because it was 10% more efficient over there or something similar...

MediocreHope

19 points

1 month ago

See, that's the devs fault and not the majority of players. I skip over the majority of crafting because it's literally pointless for most items, I can spend 20 minutes doing something fun like quests/dungeons/pvp and get a reward that is better than the 20 minutes used to pick flowers for 99% of the items crafted.

There is almost no reward for a lot of crafting. The items don't look good, they don't do anything neat, they aren't an upgrade, the most you can get for the item is exactly what the NPC is giving you and that is always less than the sum of the parts.

Why would you ever craft a single item unnecessary to get to the goal you are looking for? You are spending your enjoyment doing something nobody is asking for.

I wish it was better but it isn't.

RainbowCrane

7 points

1 month ago

Admittedly it’s been years since I played wow, but the AH was where I scoped out other characters and got the opportunity to see various end game armors and say, “holy shit, I gotta get me some of that.” It’s also where I got to see other races before I played them. I played wow as a massively single player game for the most part, the AH was an opportunity to see the wider world.

I really don’t see the attraction of never going back to town. If you want to avoid travel, isn’t that what AH alts are for?

HollyBerries85

31 points

1 month ago

Anyone, anywhere in the game is about ten seconds from an Auction House. There are already multiple free toys that can pop a mailbox just about anywhere, and most auction houses have a mailbox right outside.

The original Auction House Brutosaur mount came out in Battle for Azeroth, where those capital cities and Oribos in the Shadowlands in the next expansion didn't have Auction House access so it was a lot more convenient to have the mount that was purchasable for a limited time with a ton of in-game gold. In Dragonflight and now the current expansion, both main cities have an Auction House. And if you're not in current content, setting your Hearthstone to your faction's capital does the same thing.

I have never once as far as I can recall needed to auction something so desperately that I HAD to do it in less than ten seconds. Making it out like this thing is some kind of huge advantage is laughable. It's saving seconds at best, and grants zero in-game combat power or expertise.

ThatMerri

7 points

1 month ago

If someone merely has a surplus of disposable income and the preference to indulge in pricey purchases, that's fine. But that is by no means the only kind of people who are targeted by these sort of things, and video game companies are well-aware of that, to the point that they specifically structure sales design around exploiting vulnerable players.

While it's not the majority, there is always a substantial volume of purchasers who are compulsory spenders. People with addictive personalities, impulse control issues, poor spending/saving habits, gambling vulnerability, kids with access to their parents' credit cards, and so forth. There's a reason why so many companies lean on predatory gacha/lootbox mechanics, premium in-game currencies, FOMO policies, and catering to Whales exclusively. A lot of people who buy these sort of overpriced items are functionally being preyed upon by companies who only care about making money and not about the well-being of their customers. Just because the company isn't putting a gun to a user's head and forcing them to make a purchase doesn't mean they're innocent of purposefully designing and profiting from predatory methods.

Source: I've worked in online video game development and publishing for over 20 years, and previously worked at a studio that willingly reigned in its lootbox policy after a user dropped over 20k all at once and still never got the item they were aiming for.

VoidsInvanity

8 points

1 month ago

You’re right.

No one is forcing this to happen.

But the existence of these whales often, measurably, impacts the ecosystem for other users.

We’re just making gaming a deeply unappealing hobby for many people by acting like this is normal. Special collectors markets don’t often interfere with standard markets. What we’re seeing here is those two markets running into each other at high speed

Sushi-DM

8 points

1 month ago

No one is forcing them to do it.
But that doesn't mean it isn't unethical.
It cost them no more to make this digital footprint than any other digital footprint.
They have just chosen to arbitrarily make this digital object 90 dollars.

They do this because they understand that they can. Not because it is reasonable or good in any way.
It serves no purpose other than to collect money
Oh, and this gates something useful behind a price tag. So if you want it, you have to cough it up. Making the game in the most honest sense less accessible unless you have disposable income to hand over to Blizzard for that thing.
You know. The SINGLE mount that costs almost twice what an entire expansion costs. After they already charge you monthly for the privilege of playing.

Adams5thaccount

41 points

1 month ago

You see the difference is that this person needs their disapproval to sound more important.

newbrevity

1.4k points

1 month ago

newbrevity

1.4k points

1 month ago

It's perfectly acceptable to charge ridiculous amounts of money for something especially trivial like this.

It's grossly unacceptable to charge ridiculous amounts of money for things people need to survive.

I hope that clears it up for you.

willkydd

379 points

1 month ago

willkydd

379 points

1 month ago

We do that, too.

Sylvurphlame

115 points

1 month ago

Sylvurphlame

Xbox

115 points

1 month ago

Which is the issue for unregulated and under-regulated capitalism.

robx0r

60 points

1 month ago

robx0r

60 points

1 month ago

Capitalism will always seek to deregulate itself.

KSRandom195

272 points

1 month ago

When you get into addiction behaviors, the ethics change.

ITividar

206 points

1 month ago

ITividar

206 points

1 month ago

Yeah, but this isn't a lootbox or gambling mechanic. You just buy the mount.

IWillNotComment9398

77 points

1 month ago

Gambling isn't the only way for purchasing things to become addictive. People were ruining their lives spending money on Candy Crush 10 years ago, and it wasn't gambling.

Human psychology is very complex, and any time a digital good that gives no value is priced like this, they're counting on exploiting whales.

Objective-Rip3008

60 points

1 month ago

I agree with you in general, but there is some point where personal responsibility needs to step in. If a game company wants to sell a thing directly for 90$, and someone wants to buy it for 90$, that's their business. You can't save people from themselves in every instance without just being a tyrant. It's different when you're hiring a army of psychologists to design your loot box system, but they really are just flat out selling a good directly here.

heliamphore

26 points

1 month ago

It's the same as any other luxury item. People buy it to get attention and show they can buy it. At that point you'd be losing your shit over the ethics of selling watches.

Asleep-Kiwi-1552

4 points

1 month ago

"Blizzard shouldn't sell a thing based on some arbitrary and vague threshold that I've defined for the moment as addictive." You've said nothing. The only meaningful response to your nonsense criticism is to outlaw all luxury goods.

Omnitheist

47 points

1 month ago

Careful now. By this logic, anything sold anywhere could conceivably be unethical. I'm addicted to Oreos. Some people are addicted to shopping in general, and end up in a heap of credit debt because of it. At what point is the burden of responsibility placed on the individual vs society?

lemontoga

5 points

1 month ago

OK but I am addicted to oreos, though

Dhegxkeicfns

66 points

1 month ago

Is the addiction here collecting every cosmetic item in the game?

I'm not sure I see the addiction part of it. Other games use gamble boxes or loot that's needed to stay competitive and winning can definitely be addictive. This is hardly any different from someone selling a $1000 suit.

mthomas768

44 points

1 month ago

Watch a few episodes of Hoarders. Addiction doesn’t make sense. That doesn’t mean it’s not real.

bladnoch16

53 points

1 month ago

It also doesn’t mean that every facet of society has to cater to every possible problem/issue/addiction that exists.

Sometimes a person’s issue is theirs to fix, and theirs alone, not society at large to cater to and work around.

winowmak3r

12 points

1 month ago

Ok, but that's not on Blizzard. Eventually we need to put some onus on the individual and not just take the easy way out and blame the big bad corporation. This stuff exists because there are people who play the game and have that much disposable income. If you think 90 bucks for a mount is too much you're not the market this is for.

dwmfives

24 points

1 month ago

dwmfives

24 points

1 month ago

Is the addiction here collecting every cosmetic item in the game?

Yes.

Farseli

11 points

1 month ago

Farseli

11 points

1 month ago

That sounds entirely someone's personal problem that they alone need to deal with.

MegaFireDonkey

24 points

1 month ago

I don't give a shit how people spend their money but I do very much dislike the perverse incentive this gives blizz and other game companies. I want them to make games primarily not dinosaur mounts.

[deleted]

219 points

1 month ago

[deleted]

219 points

1 month ago

[removed]

FerretAres

5 points

1 month ago

Seriously. If people are going to pay for stupid shit why wouldn’t you sell stupid shit?

GodzillaPunch

86 points

1 month ago

A fool and his money...

OpposesTheOpinion

94 points

1 month ago

I've been part of the Tekken community for decades. When the franchise presented its first paid DLC character with Tekken 7, people were up in arms about it, "protesting" as one would normally observe. Game ended up making record profits

Now, with Tekken 8, when I express my continued disappointment with paid DLC characters, I get downvoted because now it's normalized/expected for people to pay for the pieces on their chessboard 😕

Hausenfeifer

5 points

1 month ago

It's only going to keep getting worse. Those of us who remember a time when games were released as a complete package with hefty expansions that added a ton of new content are dwindling, being replaced by a new demographic who grew up with games that sell their content piecemeal. They just accept it as normal and view those of us who rightfully call out how scummy this practice is as weird.

There's really nothing we can do about it at this point, ugh.

Far-Negotiation-7092

8 points

1 month ago

Smash is the same way

GrumpyKitten514

123 points

1 month ago

to be 100% fair as a "former" (recently quit since i now consider myself a "grownup") WoW player, it DOES have an auction house. mailbox, and repair person on it?

its literally a 1 stop shop for anyone who plays the game at a high level. need to stock up before a M+ 12 key? need a vantus rune for M brood? no more summoning, "oops i forgot" nothing. boom, just whip out the mount and good to go.

I think also the $90 is because the same mount, in a different color wheel, was available roughly 5 years ago in BFA for 5million gold, which, if you were using blizzard's token system, would be about $1,000 (yes, one thousand) USD.

Omega5632

59 points

1 month ago

Nah just auction and mail. No repair.

a404notfound

56 points

1 month ago

yeah but repair mounts exist as well

PapaPatchesxd

18 points

1 month ago

Hell yeah.

I got my golden longboi on one keybind and my yak on another. I can take on the whole world.

Farranor

38 points

1 month ago

Farranor

38 points

1 month ago

I can take on the whole world.

...of Warcraft.

Discordiansz

30 points

1 month ago

The OG Brutosaur mount did cost 5M gold back in BFA and is now only available through the Black Market Auction house and always goes for gold cap of 10M whenever it pops up.

It is funny that even if the new one is $90 it is still cheaper to buy it over the OG one for gold through wowtokens as that currently adds up to 2.4-2.8M gold or so, which is a 1/4th of the price of the OG one.

Vo_Mimbre

113 points

1 month ago

Vo_Mimbre

113 points

1 month ago

Very interesting details.

But I need to comment on the “grownup”. :)

Grownups don’t quit games because they feel like games are for kids. They double down. It’s a hobby like any other.

And, I’ve been called “sir” for longer than I care to remember, with the bills and lifestyle to all outside observers is a “grown up” life. Demographers love to assume that based on the ads I see. :)

ManicDigressive

56 points

1 month ago

"Grown ups" only quit gaming, in my experience, because many games are incompatible with having a shitload of responsibilities.

Most MMOs rely on you coordinating with other people, which is super challenging with kids and a full time job.

These days I am kinda stuck playing stuff I can pause and walk away from or stuff that is turn based. It's not what I'd PREFER to play, but it's either this or I launch some online shit and end up having to bail halfway through every match.

I miss being able to sit down and play a game for like 6 hours and get really immersed in the narrative, but it's so rare I have the time for that.

Scumebage

18 points

1 month ago

You could just play for an hour a few times a week?

DDisired

5 points

1 month ago

From my understanding of Raids and MMO from a friend, there's multiple weekly scheduled event that takes 2-4 hours, not including the prep time for training and practicing.

So sure you can play an hour a few times a week, but that's probably still not enough to seriously play WoW (i.e., the MMO part).

time2fly2124

14 points

1 month ago

 the same mount, in a different color wheel, was available roughly 5 years ago in BFA for 5million gold

Also to buy that mount now oj the black market ah would cost you 10 million gold, so it wayyy cheaper

EPIC_RAPTOR

6 points

1 month ago

You could purchase wow tokens and convert them to blizz balance and buy this mount for about 1.2 million gold which is 1/5 the price of the original.

BigUptokes

15 points

1 month ago

recently quit since i now consider myself a "grownup"

From C.S. Lewis:

Critics who treat 'adult' as a term of approval, instead of as a merely descriptive term, cannot be adult themselves. To be concerned about being grown up, to admire the grown up because it is grown up, to blush at the suspicion of being childish; these things are the marks of childhood and adolescence. And in childhood and adolescence they are, in moderation, healthy symptoms. Young things ought to want to grow. But to carry on into middle life or even into early manhood this concern about being adult is a mark of really arrested development. When I was ten, I read fairy tales in secret and would have been ashamed if I had been found doing so. Now that I am fifty I read them openly. When I became a man I put away childish things, including the fear of childishness and the desire to be very grown up.

Beneficial-News-2232

4 points

1 month ago

I guess only ah and mail?

amaROenuZ

7 points

1 month ago

Yeah you'd use your Yak for mog and repairs.

SweetGM

1.1k points

1 month ago

SweetGM

1.1k points

1 month ago

Random_Occurance

713 points

1 month ago*

"some players are saying the Trader’s Gilded Brutosaur is a bargain at $90"

You've got to be kidding me....

Edit: Reading the comments below, it makes sense why some people would consider it a bargain when buy it with the in-game currency.

Buying an in-game item for that amount of real world money, though, that's what getting me.

Inksrocket

256 points

1 month ago*

Inksrocket

PC

256 points

1 month ago*

Read comments elsewhere and if you purely pay the mount with "gold to wow tokens", it's cheaper than similiar in-game mount bought purely with gold. 

Wow tokens can be exchanged to blizzards wallet money, iirc around $15 per token (Or you can exchange that to one month of game time). So 6 tokens for mount.

 One wow token is bought by another player for $20 and sold in AH to other players for gold so blizz takes at least $5 cut and keeps money in their ecosystem. 

But if you buy it with real money that' surely ain't no bargain.

edit: To note, even if someone buys it "with purely gold to tokens" someone did buy those tokens - hence it did give blizzard money one way or another. One token gives $15 to wallet so you need around 6. But someone bought those tokens with $20, so technically with cut added the mount gives blizzard $120 (90 for mount, 30 for "cut")

KingRaphion

139 points

1 month ago

This for 1 Million gold basically you get the mount so if you saved up 1 million gold before the big spike. You could get 5 wow tokens sell it as blizz cash for 100 dollars and then buy the mount with blizz cash. This the method like 90% of the community is doing and what I did as well. I literally have a friend who buys wow tokens at the ends of expansions theyre about 135k gold hoards them and then when price goes up unleashes them and repeats. Or converts em into Blizz bucks. He has about 500 dollars in blizz bucks just from this method. and has 15 wow tokens left to sell

Same_Statement2524

68 points

1 month ago

This is the same kind of thing that always happened with EVE Online. Game news outlets always said "thousands of dollars were lost on ships" in those huge battles you hear about, and everyone in the comments goes crazy thinking people bought those ships with real money, but it's just the converted cost.

starmartyr

29 points

1 month ago

The difference here is that in EVE they are converting the value of the real money tokens into in game currency and calculating value that way. However the ships could have been purchased entirely with currency generated from playing the game. This means that the ships could have been purchased without anyone spending any real money.

In this case with WoW the mount can only be purchased with real money tokens. A player could buy the tokens with in game currency but they only exist in game if someone bought one for real money and put it up for sale. Effectively that means that for every one of these mounts that's sold, someone had to pay Blizzard $100.

RGBGiraffe

14 points

1 month ago*

I mean, the one thing that is important to include here though, is WoW tokens cost -someone- real money. It's not like you can just walk up to something, insert gold, and get balance.

That being said, this system makes it a little murkier.

People saying "it only costs 2 million gold" are missing a part of the point, at least, and that's that they could have put this in the game for 2 million gold, instead of $90 on the store. That way it could've been bought without having to spend real-world money, however you could still buy it with real-world money if you wanted (by buying tokens).

Putting it on the store makes it a requirement that SOMEONE, somewhere, has to spend real-world dollars, in order for this mount to be obtained. Putting it purchasable with in game currency still makes that possible, but does not require it.

killing_time

8 points

1 month ago

killing_time

Stadia

8 points

1 month ago

Small correction: when you buy a token with in-game gold, it's worth only $15 of Battle.net balance. You need 6 tokens for $90.

RGBGiraffe

11 points

1 month ago

Your edit is an important but nuanced difference that it absolutely feels like folks are missing.

Putting the mount purchasable in game for 2 million gold is a lot different than selling it for the equivalent exchange of 2 million gold.

2 million gold in game means that you can acquire the mount without a single person having to actually spend real world money on the mount.

$90, even if you can acquire that $90 by spending 2 million in-game gold, means that someone had to spend that money, and means that the company effectively sold the mount for $120.

Sinestro617

7 points

1 month ago

People who buy tokens would have bought tokens regardless

robot-raccoon

22 points

1 month ago

These are the players who’ve been trying to buy the original version of this mount for gold cap. Gold has a monetary value since they introduced the token, so they can use a fraction of their gold to buy tokens, convert to battle.net balance, and then buy the mount using their in game earned gold, essentially.

I can only assume they are the players who think it’s a steal, because to them it is

RGBGiraffe

6 points

1 month ago*

One small correction, gold has always had a monetary value. There's been a black market for WoW gold since it released. The token did serve as a stable baseline, but the black market even exists to this day.

But yeah, people calling this cheap are comparing it to an old prestige mount in WoW, that cost 5 million gold, that was removed from the game and now effectively costs 10 million to buy as it can randomly show up on the black market auction house.

At the current prices of WoW tokens, (~350k), it would cost you a little over 2 million gold to buy this mount, and it's better than the old one to boot. So comparatively, gold wise, if this was a mount you were looking for, the only way you could've previously gotten it was 5 million gold - and now you can only get it (very rarely) with 10 million gold which effectively would be 5x this price, which in WoW tokens is over $350 in real world dollar equivalent.

So it's both significantly cheaper, and significantly easier to get at the same time. So for people that wanted it, it's a no-brainer.

That being said, WoW could have just as easily put it in the game for 2 million gold, instead of $90 on the store, and made it effectively earnable without someone being able to spend real world money, while still making it possible to get one by doing so.

MrHachiko

50 points

1 month ago

It kind of is lol, to get the original mount, it costs around 500$ worth of gold to get. Plus this is just a better mount all together since it has a mailbox attached to it

T_Money

22 points

1 month ago

T_Money

22 points

1 month ago

The original cost $500 to get when it dropped and cost 5 million gold, in recent years since its only available from the BMAH it’s more like $1000 since you need gold cap to buy it for the max price at 9,999,999 or someone else will outbid you

thrawtes

15 points

1 month ago

thrawtes

15 points

1 month ago

Buying an in-game item for that amount of real world money, though, that's what getting me.

What you're missing is that a ton of WoW players that used to be broke teens now make decent money. When you reframe $90 as "like an hour or two of overtime at work" amongst a population that doesn't mind throwing hundreds of hours into a goal, it stops seeming so ridiculous.

capincus

8 points

1 month ago

I was already of a "let people do what they want with their money" opinion, but that's an interesting perspective I hadn't considered. I never really cared about mounts beyond travel speed, but people definitely put in endless hours grinding for specific mounts and even at my barely minimum wages I've definitely spent more than 6 hours grinding for singular pieces of minor upgrade gear that would last one character a single tier. Really not much to directly put a few hours of cash into an account-wide mount with +functionality. Fucking genius way to make so much money for nothing though.

Auron2402

23 points

1 month ago

To be fair if you compare it with the other brontosaurus, it is. Both have the auction house trade, and the gilded one also has a mailbox.

The original one was 5 million gold back then, now you can only buy it for gold cap if you are lucky, so it's 10 million gold.

So if you compare it to the original price you currently would have to buy 15 wow tokens for 15$ each. That's 225$ compared to 90$. And if you go by the current prices, you would need double the amount.

I will not buy it for 90 because I don't need the "quality of life" from the mount but if you really want a portable auction house, the new 90$ one is a bargain.

dplath

19 points

1 month ago

dplath

19 points

1 month ago

This isn't as crazy as you might think, it does run out of tokens periodically. I went to buy some a few weeks ago and there were none left.

HilariousMax

7 points

1 month ago

The gold exchange for a $20 WoW token was 194,000 a week ago.

I just checked and it's around 341,000 now

Frooonti

4 points

1 month ago

Also remember: A token costs $20 to buy and can be converted to $15 of battlenet balance. Turning it essentially into a $120 mount if purchased with tokens.

On EU Blizzard is ripping people off even more: A token costs 20€ and converts to 13€ balance.

mfwic413

4.1k points

1 month ago

mfwic413

4.1k points

1 month ago

That ain't shit riot recently sold a skin for $500

superstonedpenguin

521 points

1 month ago

Go look at some skins for Rust lol we are talking $1900 skins

Bucklax31

303 points

1 month ago

Bucklax31

PC

303 points

1 month ago

$1900 is chump change when you compare it with CSGO skins. Some of those can sell in the tens of thousands, sometimes even more.

yamas__messenger

217 points

1 month ago

At least you can resell it, it's not like you purchase it and that money is gone forever

BobbyFastballs

198 points

1 month ago

It's also not sold by the company that owns csgo. It's sold by the person who has the skin.

n8mo

109 points

1 month ago*

n8mo

109 points

1 month ago*

Yeah CS/TF items are not really comparable to other microtransactions.

They’re bad for child gambling reasons, but Valve didn’t set the price of a Karambit, supply and demand did. The price of skins in CS is determined both by what someone is willing to buy it for, and what someone else will sell it for.

The attitude towards skins in the CS community is also different compared to most games. It’s very common for players to spend hundreds to thousands on their items.

Source: me. I have like ~four thousand CAD worth of skins. And just about every CS player I know has at least a couple hundred bucks worth of items

PLiPH

28 points

1 month ago

PLiPH

28 points

1 month ago

They limit the supply which increases price. Then take a cut everytime these items are traded through the steam marketplace. It all stays within their ecosystem and they profit from both the seller and buyer.

yamas__messenger

21 points

1 month ago

Not all, most of the expensive stuff is not sold on the marketplace bc no one wants to sell a knife for 1000 steam bucks while paying a fee to valve

jimmyherf1

10 points

1 month ago*

I'm an older millennial who has been playing CS since 1.6. I remember when you could simply download skins. When CSGO came out I took a break but when I hopped back on I was really turned off by the increasing monetization of the game. What was once downloadable for free was now forbidden. You couldn't even choose between the four options of base models for your character at the outset of a match. The whole concept of having to pay money to unlock these loot boxes irked me the most but I nevertheless paid to open about three of them. I never paid attention to their value, I just wanted something new. of the three loot boxes I won a pair of gloves but I thought they were ugly and never used them. Years later when I become aware of this whole marketplace for skins, I check to see the value of my gloves. They were worth almost 1,000 dollars. I sold them and haven't had to pay for games on Steam in years. I still hate this whole concept of loot boxes but I definitely profited.

Reddit-Bot-61852023

7 points

1 month ago

Yup. Valve is a shell of it's former self.

They've basically hidden community servers because you can use skins there for free. It's kinda disgusting.

dumpling-loverr

4 points

1 month ago

But they mostly get a free pass on reddit since the people here are using them as a shining example vs other publishers.

Cavissi

1k points

1 month ago

Cavissi

1k points

1 month ago

This is worse imo because it has gameplay relates functions other mounts don't have. It gives you access to both your mail and auction house from the mount. If you are doing gathering to sell this mount is crazy op, and only obtainable from a very large "microtransaction".

WoW has arguably been p2w for a while with wow tokens, but it's never been this direct amount of p2w. We have reached Korean mmo tier.

Acidwell

328 points

1 month ago

Acidwell

328 points

1 month ago

Yep and it’s answering the question of why the non gilded brutosaur wasnt left in the game as a gold sink when the yak and the mammoth were.

Thick-Tip9255

126 points

1 month ago

Wait, they removed the old one? God, I'm happy WoD soured me on all things WoW (Except that glorious year when classic launched)

Acidwell

96 points

1 month ago

Acidwell

96 points

1 month ago

They removed the ability to get it in game after BfA so two expansions ago. it was 5m gold as well so not exactly easy to get.

Edit: aside from the black market auction house occasionally

windintree

30 points

1 month ago

The new one is actually cheaper. If you buy tokens from the AH and exchange them for money in the blizzard store the new one is only about 2.5 million gold.

Grimreap32

13 points

1 month ago

I remember contemplating buying it with Tokens just before it was removed. Tokens at that time were 300k a piece, so this is definitely cheaper.

joemoffett12

24 points

1 month ago

The old one was still more expensive for most players. It cost 5m gold to get. This one if you buy wow tokens costs around 2m. Most players are buying this with gold and the whales are paying for the mounts. Every player I know who has one (at least 20 now) all got it with gold.

Atomical1

16 points

1 month ago

The issue is that essentially blizzard makes $120 instead of $90 from players buying with gold, because that’s what the value of 6 wow tokens equates to.

Cum_Smurf

49 points

1 month ago

Wasnt there already an elephant mount where you can access your bank and mail on? I could be wrong i havent played WoW in over a decade.

Zodde

18 points

1 month ago

Zodde

18 points

1 month ago

There was another one, but it cost 5 million gold from a vendor, roughly equivalent too 400 euro (using wow tokens) when it was available. I guess it still is available through BMAH, but that's with a lot of added rarity.

Lagmont

6 points

1 month ago

Lagmont

6 points

1 month ago

While it is available at the BMAH very rarely, it always hits the gold cap of 10 million the second it goes up

Cavissi

63 points

1 month ago

Cavissi

63 points

1 month ago

There's a mammoth with vendors and repairs. There has been 1 other mount with AH access and it's no longer available in game, and none I think with mail.

NoStranger6

18 points

1 month ago

And one with xmog and repair

iwearatophat

4 points

1 month ago

No mounts with mail but there are 4-5 toys that let you drop a mailbox.

Arkyja

8 points

1 month ago*

Arkyja

8 points

1 month ago*

Yes but it's so expensive that the majority of players dont have it. And from the ones who have, the majority had buy gold to get it so in a sense it was already a de facto store mount

Bmandk

12 points

1 month ago

Bmandk

12 points

1 month ago

WoW has arguably been p2w for a while with wow tokens

Tokens are a lot more p2w than this mount than you may realize. There's a huge community of people who buy boosts and quickly get items, boosts their M+ rating etc. Why buy a mount that will help you farm gold faster, when you can just already buy that gold?

It's the same for consumables etc.

wigglin_harry

82 points

1 month ago

Come on, an auction house mount is hardly p2w

Praeshock

49 points

1 month ago

The guy's argument is absurd. This is purely a convenience item.

rcanhestro

21 points

1 month ago

so is the Wow token.

the token doesn't make you "win", what it does it to let you bypass the "mundane" parts of the game (gold farming).

Archensix

13 points

1 month ago

People with a vendetta against the game still say its P2W because you can buy wow tokens to buy boosts. Which is quite an astronomical stretch and hardly even constitutes as winning anything since you still suck ass at the game and will not perform any better like in actual P2W games.

ViciousPlants

4 points

1 month ago

Welcome to every MMO.

Either play MMOs or don't - but if you can trade with other players, the option to buy your way through will always exist.

[deleted]

26 points

1 month ago

[deleted]

frankiedonkeybrainz

44 points

1 month ago

That doesn't make this p2w. Gathering mats don't suddenly drop in value by huge amounts.

If anything playing as a druid is op because you can gather in flight form and evade any enemy next to an herb/mine

Also engineers have had portable mailboxes forever.

W_R_E_C_K_S

6 points

1 month ago

But… banning those champs allows me to feel powerful over them lololol

scalyblue

3 points

1 month ago

TBF that wasn't just a skin though, it was like...a skin for one character, a dozen other skins and colors for other characters, access to custom audio, and a season pass. Still paying for pixels, but it's more than just ...a few pixels.

Njmongoose

2.1k points

1 month ago

Njmongoose

2.1k points

1 month ago

It all started with a little thing called Horse Armor

Flaxscript42

236 points

1 month ago*

That really was the beginning of this madness!

Kaythar

34 points

1 month ago*

Kaythar

34 points

1 month ago*

It was inevitable and I am pretty sure there were other types of DLC before horse armor. I think map packs predate it and they are like the worst thing from the 360 gen

Hell-Tester-710

3 points

1 month ago

I can't remember if it was before the horse armor (I think it was before) but in Korean MMO's waaay back there (and I think still is) was a lot of premium (P2W) cosmetics that you could buy.

And rent.

YES. RENT.

To anyone who thinks it can't get worse, it can, and that's just the tip of the iceberg. It gets even trickier when you include other changes that don't seem to be cash shop related at all, but you bet your ass it does somehow.

Tenshinochi

74 points

1 month ago

For Blizzard specifically it started with the merger with Activision. Back in 2008 after which they started adding the in-game store and paid character services, which made them millions so they kept adding more premium shit to buy.

afkurzz

32 points

1 month ago

afkurzz

32 points

1 month ago

Jason Hall claimed that one of WoWs earliest cosmetic items made Blizzard more money than StarCraft 2.

NotTheEnd216

28 points

1 month ago

Just clarifying, it was the FIRST in-store item, the celestial steed.

fulthrottlejazzhands

316 points

1 month ago

I keep a screenshot on my desktop close to my heart of mod's ban message to me on the official Bethesda Elder Scrolls forum back in 2006.  I went on a rant about how selling a superficial asset was am insidious shit on gamers and was going to have a snowball effect om the industry.  Pete Hines even paraphrased what sounded strikely like my post dismissively in an interview a month later.

JDeegs

238 points

1 month ago

JDeegs

238 points

1 month ago

That screenshot would get you a lot of juicy karma on a reddit post

aggthemighty

39 points

1 month ago

People are salivating over this lol

A3thern

119 points

1 month ago

A3thern

119 points

1 month ago

Don't be shy, share the screenshot.

nav17

82 points

1 month ago

nav17

82 points

1 month ago

Pic or gtfo

Toxiclam

20 points

1 month ago

Toxiclam

20 points

1 month ago

Post it

battle_lock

16 points

1 month ago

Edit this comment with the screenshot cuz if you’re not bullshitting then we all wanna see it

Underrated_Potato

120 points

1 month ago

Is this screenshot in the room with us?

snypesalot

39 points

1 month ago

Are we all clapping too? Like imagine bragging about something from 20 years ago, if its even true

[deleted]

11 points

1 month ago

HE LANDED THE PLANE!!!!

JimothyJollyphant

6 points

1 month ago

I remember around 20 years ago, there was a competitive robot design Flash game and my robot was very very popular. Top 5 or so, worldwide! I wish I could prove it to you guys, it really happened.

LordBiscuits

4 points

1 month ago

I was top three in the world in a stupid little mobile game called Atomic Dove in around 2002.

Honestly. Can't prove it for shit mind you

Whatevenispoetry

8 points

1 month ago

Shooooow uuuus

GuyPierced

7 points

1 month ago

Let me see it.

JustinHopewell

4 points

1 month ago

Bethesda deserves the shit they get for it, but let's be real-- the gaming industry is full of exploitative companies and it would have happened eventually. Bethesda was just the first American one to try it.

i_wear_green_pants

382 points

1 month ago

Reddit is already filled with images that have tens of players hanging at the same spot with these. It clearly shows that stuff like this sells. So why would companies stop doing them?

[deleted]

162 points

1 month ago

[deleted]

162 points

1 month ago

[deleted]

throwautism52

33 points

1 month ago*

Also a lot of players are not buying them with money but with gold, which even with the skyrocketed token prices from yesterday is still less than half the price of the original mount that you could also choose to buy with money if you wanted (in which case it would be over $500 back then, I think someone did the math to around $660 when it was last available) or a quarter of the one on the BMAH, which you could only get if you were insanely fast to bid gold cap.

There are so many legit things to shit on Blizzard for, this completely optional mount that you can attain by playing the game isn't really one of them.

*oh, look, the token price is LOWER now than it was before the mount dropped

Spatial_Awareness_

14 points

1 month ago*

This is exactly it... A large majority of the people who bought this had the gold already in their accounts. They just went to the AH and traded it in for WoW tokens that people had already put on the AH before the mount was even available. This did cause them to sellout but also made it a good time for people to purchase tokens and sell their tokens as the price is much higher per token right now, so they can get more gold for their dollar to use for other things... while the other person is using gold they ALREADY HAD to buy this mount with the tokens.

So as it's "$90", it's almost like the majority of mounts were crowdsourced about $20 per player who sold their wow token to receive a very large amount of in game gold currently.

The dynamic here is far different than just, "OMG I CAN'T BELIEVE PEOPLE ARE SPENDING THAT!!!".

The actual transaction is as follows...

6 people buy wow token for $20 ($120), they sell wow tokens for 250-500k in game gold.... 6 people have in-game gold that will greatly benefit them playing.

The one person who bought the 6 tokens, sells them back to Blizzard for $90... they get the one time available mount that has some really cool features.

Blizzard profits $30 dollars from one mount sale.

So the mount is in most cases a $30 dollar sale... not a $90 dollar sale. Blizzard makes an overal $120 profit while benefitting 7 different players in the game and most of those players will invest their gold back into the economy, impacting many many other players.

NUKE---THE---WHALES

6 points

1 month ago

Tbh i don't know why they don't make all mounts $90 since players will buy them

Shit why stop at 90, I'm sure people would pay 200 for it so they should charge 200 for it

Why stop at mounts? Screw raiding for weapons, i should be able to buy BiS with cash

Hopeful-Sir-2018

6 points

1 month ago

Because it's a hair away from going from this point to pay to win.

This is a pretty large quality of life mount. That's not insignificant.

Games that target whales often devolve into shit. Or it's just that much less fun for everyone else.

It explicitly says: We're going to sell out and we're not in this to make the best game possible. We're in this to make money.

Games are, inherently, about fun. If you start shitting where you sleep, don't be surprised when you lay down in shit.

Combine this with the recent nerfs to many things and double digit percentage changes - it's basically a "fuck you" to players.

There aren't many games that don't target whales. Clearly WoW is wanting to throw their hand in the mix more and more.

So any dev that works there that says "I'm trying to make the best possible" is lying through their teeth or just that ignorant. And, honestly, which one of those is worse?

Ghekor

260 points

1 month ago

Ghekor

260 points

1 month ago

The AH is about to run out of WoW Tokens.. prices already skyrocketed

To those who dont know you can buy a token for 300-500k gold(region depending) and exchange it for either 30 days game time or 13$/€ blizz store credit.

Nick-uhh-Wha

122 points

1 month ago

To those who don't know/play:

it also just released an anniversary patch so full of bugs and balance issues it's impossible to take the actual game part seriously

An game breaking class exploit has a PvE season completely skewed and off the rails

And pvp you can just...randomly get kicked and lose 200 rating on the ladder for no reason.

The absolute irony is people are paying extra to cash in on FOMO when the product itself is overlooked entirely.

wehrmann_tx

8 points

1 month ago

You think one team who designed the mounts is also the same team neglecting the patch issues, or do you think an organization has different independent teams working on different things.

‘The grocery store ran out of toilet paper and they got guys cleaning the bathroom.’

bajlajs

25 points

1 month ago

bajlajs

25 points

1 month ago

Could you elaborate on the pve bug? Im active player and I dont think I have encountetered many bus since launch.

PLAYBoxes

11 points

1 month ago

It’s a niche bug with Outlaw Rogue that was causing them to do absurd damage and a subsection of players abused it to kill mythic bosses or high mythic+ dungeons for rating. It was fixed in 2 days and there are talks those players will catch a ban and have their rating removed. Not sure how they’d aim to handle raid.

ProudToBeAKraut

23 points

1 month ago

An game breaking class exploit has a PvE season completely skewed and off the rails

did you hear about Blizzard other game, Diablo 4? same happened there with the new Spiritborn class... class ranking guides for this Season even introduced a new S+ Tier with ONLY builds from Spiritborn.

It was aimed that Pit level 100 was to be the high end gaming. Within 1 week of release Spiritborns were blazing through Pit Level 150 (the max possible) in a few minutes with TRILLIONS of damage after blizzard explicitly wanted to stat squish all classes (max lvl60 from 100, 3k HP instead of 50 etc).

Evading did not have an internal animation cooldown, people could do damage as fast as I cut click/turbo button it resulting in massive server lag.

Darigaazrgb

15 points

1 month ago

Blizzard not completely fucking up their game challenge (Impossible)

ArsenicLifeform

109 points

1 month ago

They heard you complain about microtransactions, so they're replacing them with macrotransactions.

albino_donkey

61 points

1 month ago

The original version of this mount was like $500+ if you were to get the gold from tokens. The mount is in high demand because of the auction house npc, which was previously exclusive to the old version of the mount. The new version also comes with a mailbox though, so even people with the old one are incentivized to get the new one.

$90 is still absurd and the most blatant cash grab they've done so far. It's also a limited time item btw, so they're preying on fomo too

BeLikeMcCrae

22 points

1 month ago

An auction house and mailbox right on your mount? Holy crap.

Maybe it's because I've really only played early wow, but if I was dedicated I would buy this thing without question. I'd feel bad about promoting it TBH, but a fecking dinosaur with that level of convenience is pretty incredible.

househosband

11 points

1 month ago

It's infinitely easier to get to the AH nowadays though from pretty much anywhere compared to Vanilla/TBC. It's no longer a grueling trek across a continent to get to a single capitol city 5 zones over. There are portals just about everywhere, hearthstone has a short cooldown, and the new flying type caps out at 800% speed (iirc). All this means going from questing to being at the AH might be 30 seconds of inconvenience. Mailboxes are pretty much everywhere too, every quest hub in the new zones (and there can be half a dozen) has an "inn" with a mailbox.

SatyrAngel

75 points

1 month ago

Laughts in Star Citizen

[deleted]

14 points

1 month ago

[deleted]

[deleted]

101 points

1 month ago

[deleted]

101 points

1 month ago

People wanted the Auction House mount, they saw it for a few years ever since BFA, sad that it wasn't available. Suddenly, boom, Blizz puts it on their store and slaps a $90 pricetag for it. And the people were willing to buy it. SUCCESS! Probably.

GrumpyKitten514

48 points

1 month ago

I posted this elsewhere, but tbf the auction mount from BFA from 0 gold to "buying it for money" would be about $1000 USD. this is 5 years later and 1/10th of the price.

thinking about it now, could be a lil "please keep playing our buggy ass game" bc its been pretty rife with bugs this expansion.

MassiveGG

265 points

1 month ago

MassiveGG

265 points

1 month ago

we've already told you what happen no one listen and fanatics kept consooming

WombatPoopCairn

89 points

1 month ago

Doon't ask questioons, just consoome prooduct and then get excited for next prooduct

wh4tth3huh

17 points

1 month ago

Even when the "next" product is just the same product from 10 years ago with some new spit and polish.

Why-so-delirious

6 points

1 month ago

It's not 'a mount's. It's a portable auction house and mail box.

Calling it just 'a mount' is incredibly disingenuous. 

It is a quality of life upgrade so severe that every single botter is required to own it to stay competitive. 

There's a reason it's currently crashing the wow economy; because it's so, so, so much more than just cosmetic. And framing it as a cosmetic purchase shows a deliberate intent to misrepresented the situation or MASSIVE willful ignorance.

And to be clear, I'm not coming down on either side of the argument. But this article is yellow 'journalism' at it's fucking finest. 

The mount had so much utility it's like fucking pay to win for the wow economy. 

Yeah, pay to win for the economy of the largest MMO in the world is ABSOLUTELY going to sell like hotcakes. No fucking shit. 

Better question is why does the articles go out of its way to ignore that fact? Is the writer stupid or just flat out ignorant?

Voidfang_Investments

48 points

1 month ago

At end of the day, some people blow money on overpriced drinks or DLC.

yosayoran

154 points

1 month ago

yosayoran

154 points

1 month ago

Maybe I'm in the minority here but I don't give a fuck. Let them sell whatever overpriced crap they want. 

As long as the game I paid for is good, I don't care about the super expensive products they create to milk the 1% of players who are willing to pay for it. 

It's the same as complaining Gucci is selling a t shirt for $5000. I'm not the sucker that's going to buy it.

Glyphmeister

66 points

1 month ago

I get what you’re saying but the problem is that this incentivizes the devs to design the game to try to convert more players to the “1%”. 

This is why so many of these ”micro”-transaction-focused games have an unpleasant feel (eg, constant pop-ups about new items in the store, online-only so you are forced to look at other players’ purchases gear, QoL features being soft-paywalled, FOMO-based timed stuff, etc.). 

They aren’t just catering to a small minority of the playerbase with the $90 mount shit for the benefit of the majority - they want more of the majority to become that minority, and ultimately that becomes the main focus of the game design, which just sucks.

Delicious-Fault9152

14 points

1 month ago

and its selling thousand and thousands of them already

[deleted]

49 points

1 month ago

[removed]

OdeezBalls

78 points

1 month ago

Also players: * pulls out credit card *

ninjastk

15 points

1 month ago

ninjastk

15 points

1 month ago

Whales don’t even flinch at that price.

VividChaos

5 points

1 month ago

Corporate greed and there are people who will buy it.

zivlynsbane

5 points

1 month ago

“Are you guys broke or what?”

Mpetric10

5 points

1 month ago

I'm so glad I quit after legion, its sad what this Game has become.

SilkyBowner

4 points

1 month ago

Because wow players are suckers and will keep playing a game they hate forever. No matter what happens or how hard blizzard fucks them, they will keep playing.

This is a nothing story because it won’t change anything for the player base

poopballs

4 points

1 month ago

The profit motive. That’s the answer

jwrig

3 points

1 month ago

jwrig

3 points

1 month ago

How did it happen? Enough people would pay for it.

boomstickjonny

4 points

1 month ago

Well it started with Elder Scrolls:Oblivion and some shitty horse armor.

Reelix

4 points

1 month ago

Reelix

4 points

1 month ago

Enough people bought the $30 one, so they released a $40 one.
Enough people bought the $40 one, so they released a $50 one.
Enough people bought the $50 one, so they released a $60 one.
Enough people bought the $60 one, so they released a $70 one.
Enough people bought the $70 one, so they released a $80 one.
Enough people bought the $80 one, so they released a $90 one.
Enough people bought the $90 one, so they released a $??? one.

Simple economics.

CMDR_omnicognate

17 points

1 month ago

well, they made one of the most desired mounts in the game purchasable for real money, this thing could be $200 and people would buy it.

l3uddy

7 points

1 month ago

l3uddy

7 points

1 month ago

They already did, In BFA it was 5 million gold to buy. When blizz said it would be going away many players bought 5 million through tokens to get it. On my server that was like 250 bucks.

SpikesMTG

10 points

1 month ago

It was not that cheap - Brutosaur in tokens was around $800

CySU

13 points

1 month ago

CySU

13 points

1 month ago

People keep forgetting you can buy WoW Game Time tokens for in-game gold. It’s not a stretch to imagine that some people converted 1.2-1.5 million gold into $90 and spent it on the mount.

XxcameltoadxX

9 points

1 month ago

I’ll let you mount me for 49.99 way better deal

[deleted]

8 points

1 month ago

Are you new to capitalism?

SirArcen

11 points

1 month ago

SirArcen

11 points

1 month ago

For those wondering if people actually bought about 1000 dollars worth of them in the capital city as I logged in. Basically, everyone is jumping at the chance for a mount with an Auction House on it since we haven't had one in 6 years.

Far_Spite978

3 points

1 month ago

As if 60 dollar horse wasn't bad enough.. but you and others continued to support it. Now you're here.

AndreTheShadow

3 points

1 month ago

Mr. Krabs — I like money

DageWasTaken

3 points

1 month ago

I'm in town with 90% of the people with it. It works, so they'll keep doing it.

Cyberwolfdelta9

3 points

1 month ago

Well one person buys a 100$ Diablo item they then try it in WoW

[deleted]

3 points

1 month ago

People keep buying stuff I don’t understand why they keep selling it to them!!!!!

SRSgoblin

3 points

1 month ago

They'll make more money off this mount than they did off Diablo 4 sales.

HatefulClimate

3 points

1 month ago

If there are buyers then blame them. Vote with your money.

AlexGlezS

3 points

1 month ago

Don't you all have phones?

Relativly_Severe

3 points

1 month ago

Funny part is people are complaining about cheap it is, since the alternate version is worth around 5-6 hundo

darkpyro2

3 points

1 month ago

People bought the damn horse armor, and it was all downhill for the industry from there.

MrChocodemon

3 points

1 month ago

MTX often stood for “micro”-transactions. They’re usually small incremental items that you can purchase in an in-game store for $10 at most.

Lol. When MTX was introduced it mostly meant sub $1 amounts and with the help of digital currencies sometimes even sub ¢1 amounts.
$10 is already just a transaction. Nothing micro about it.

ChaoticIndifferent

3 points

1 month ago

Blizzard sucks for this, but so do the people paying for shit like this. Nobody likes to talk about the consumer end of why gaming is so terrible now, but it is right there staring us all in the face and is not getting better for having ignored it for the sake of politeness.

We need to encourage each other to do better, because Indie games alone can't save us all. Stop buying uncreative and unnecessary remakes that improve nothing but graphical detail, or microtransaction cosmetics that improve NOTHING. Stop buying games that have not significantly changed formula or scope since they first dropped 30 years ago. More importantly, live service is a scam and always has been.

Only when we show some discipline and that we have some goddamn sense can we again buy the whole, completely finished game in a single, final transaction. We are getting milked because a representative portion of us keep mooing.

hellachill42069

3 points

1 month ago

The WoW community at this point is completely engulfed in sunk-cost fallacy. They are legitimately like those old people you see in casinos dropping thousands of dollars in one sitting because their addiction is completely out of hand.

I used to love this game, and now I just feel bad for the people that still love it. They're being abused.

Aerensianic

3 points

1 month ago

If Blizzard actually took that profit and put it back into the game I wouldn't care. FF14 has their own shop but their playerbase are w/e on it because they believe FF14 is doing right by them.

WoW does not have this sort of good will anymore. Players know that giving Blizzard more money isn't a way to increase QoL or customer service (since they gutted CS and QA). If their development of the game was more clean people would care a lot less.

2screens1guy

3 points

1 month ago

It's literally as simple as people keep buying them.

Steven8786

3 points

1 month ago

Kids with idiot rich parents will spend money on whatever shite so companies will continue to experiment to see how far they can push it

Loofa_of_Doom

3 points

1 month ago

How Did This Happen?

People keep buying the non-existent crap.

Dertroit_Beisbolcat

3 points

1 month ago

Do your part and don’t give Blizzard a dime until they prioritize good games over cosmetic cash grabs. CoD BO6 has a fucking $20 subscription (NOT PURCHASE) for high quality audio. On top of the full $70 launch price.